The TastePodcast

Tom Rinaldi

Tom Rinaldi grew up in San Francisco, enjoyed the Summer of Love, and tasted wine in Napa Valley on his motorcycle. Later he signed up for the Navy before entering UC Davis where he studied winemaking -- and the rest is history. He’s been winemaker for Round Hill, Duckhorn, Provenance, Pellet Estate, and others. His sense of adventure intact, Tom looks forward to many more vintages to come. Enjoy! For more visit: PelletEstate.com

57 min listen46 min read

Tom Rinaldi on The Taste

Interview transcript

Doug Shafer

Um, have a great guy on today. Long time friend, long time winemaker, Tom Rinaldi. Tom's been founding winemaker at at least three wineries that I know about: Round Hill, Duckhorn, Provenance. And Tom, good to s- good to have you on. I can't remember when we first met. Do you? Where did we first meet? Any idea?

Tom Rinaldi

Oh boy. I'd bet that was around the t- about 1978 is my bet. I was getting grapes in the neighborhood and, uh, uh, your dad was a buddy. I d- I v- maybe the Vintner's Association. Maybe a, at Calistoga tastings.

Doug Shafer

Y- yeah, the old-

Tom Rinaldi

Things like that.

Doug Shafer

The old wine tech thing up at the Calistoga. The hanging beef dinners, remember those?

Tom Rinaldi

Exactly. Oh boy.

Doug Shafer

(laughs) And, and it might've been-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, that goes back to the '70s.

Doug Shafer

It does. And I think, well, we have something in common, because I wasn't around full time till early '80s, but dad's first Cab was a '78 and Duckhorn's first Merlot was a '78, so I remember meeting Dan through, Dan Duckhorn through my dad. That's probably where I met up with you at some point, back in there, those days, anyway. But, uh...

Tom Rinaldi

Sure.

Doug Shafer

Lot- long time ago.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, th- I spent the first 22 vintages there.

Doug Shafer

Ah.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh-huh. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

I know you did. I know you did. But before you-

Tom Rinaldi

Good, good memories.

Doug Shafer

Before you went to Duckhorn, let's go all the way back. Before Napa, before winemaking, you know, where were you born? Where'd you grow up? Talk to me.

Tom Rinaldi

I was born in San Francisco and my dad and his mom were born in San Francisco. Uh, my mother was conceived in Sicily and born in Brooklyn, but, uh, she managed to meet up with my dad and had three, uh, three sons. Uh, I was the middle. In fact, uh, my birthday's next Saturday. Uh, f- 71.

Doug Shafer

Wow. No way.

Tom Rinaldi

Mm-hmm (affirmative). Yeah. Way.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

But, um, I, I went to St. Ignatius High School, very proud of that. Played football. We won the city championship, uh, that year.

Doug Shafer

Nice.

Tom Rinaldi

And then, uh, at 17 I signed up for the military and went in the Navy. And, uh, that was that. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

So-

Tom Rinaldi

We got a good idea.

Doug Shafer

Like, if it's, growing up in San Francisco, that must've been, that was, god, was that with Haight Ashbury and all that, and the hippies and the flower children and all that jazz? Was that going on?

Tom Rinaldi

Exactly.

Doug Shafer

Oh. (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

I got caught right in the middle of it. I got to meet Janice Joplin. I, I, I had a long conversation with Jerry Garcia. I was there, man. I mean, I s- I was there for their first concert, both Big B- d- or, and the Holding Company, with Janice Joplin, and, uh, the Vandals becoming, uh, the Grateful Dead.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And they were right down the street, you know? And it was pretty cool to be, uh, part of that.

Doug Shafer

You were, like, what, high school?

Tom Rinaldi

Yes. Yes.

Doug Shafer

God. I can't even believe what that was like. The, so, you're, th- you're in the middle of that whole scene, the summer of love and all that, and then, but meanwhile you got the Giants and the Niners. Were you, were you tracking all that? 'Cause I know you're...

Tom Rinaldi

Oh, sure.

Doug Shafer

...a big Giants fan. Yeah. Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. And my mom, since she was born in Brooklyn, was a Dodgers fan.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And I mean, we were watching Sandy Koufax throwing a no hitter against the Giants, we were on our hands and knees begging, "Please, somebody get a hit."

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And she is just, "Yahoo!" Dodger blue for...

Doug Shafer

Dodger-

Tom Rinaldi

...her last breath. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

Oh, that's, that's amazing. Um...

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

What a scene. So, growing up, wine in the house?

Tom Rinaldi

Yes. I wasn't much of a wine guy, I tell you the truth. Um, but when I turned 16, I had a motorcycle. I was 15 and a half. And I came up to the Napa Valley at 16 years old. And as long as I took the tour, I could do a tasting.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And I did the tasting, I could buy some. And so I'd buy some Green Hungarian for, you know, two dollars and share it with my gal friend who was sitting on the back of the bike.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, so I kinda, I don't know. It wasn't really showing off, but it was kinda cool that, uh, there was no carding or anything getting weird about, uh, some kid buying some-

Doug Shafer

You- (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

Some wine to enjoy.

Doug Shafer

Wait, let me get this straight. You're 16, and the drinking age is 21. Maybe it was 18, it was that for a while.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, it was 21.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

And, uh, but they're serving you no problem. (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

No problem. I never had a problem. W- it was the darnedest thing. Typically it was summertime...

Doug Shafer

Oh. So, where - what, what wineries did you go to? What, where was, what was going on back then?

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, BV was one of my favorite. In fact, uh, I bought some, uh, Georges de Latour way back in, uh, oh boy. That would've been, uh, the '63 vintage.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, that was, uh, $3 a bottle, and then they jacked up the price to $3.50 with the '64 coming out.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And that was definitely high end. And, um, those I kept in my parents' cellar. The rest of them, I, I would party with. And I'd go to Martini. And, uh, Krug. And across the street was, uh, Christian Brothers.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

Back then, it was, uh, sparkling wine, and that was pretty exciting.

Doug Shafer

And that's the, uh, that's currently the, what, the, the home of the CIA. Greystone.

Tom Rinaldi

Correct.

Doug Shafer

So, so, all right. So you graduated from high school and you joined the Navy. What, what's that story?

Tom Rinaldi

Well, um, needed to get away.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Tell you the truth, uh, the f- my friends were starting to get into more and more hard drugs, and, uh, I didn't really wanna get caught up in that.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, I, I j- and I didn't wanna, really wasn't ready for college and I wasn't ready for a job, so, uh, it just seemed like a good alternative. I was in good shape, and, uh, studied all the test and just really, you know, cut off all my hair and, (laughs) you know, went in. I, I had 120 days to basically, uh, I was in the reserves and, uh, just, uh, before I had to report to boot camp. And I was excited, to tell you the truth. And I, I d- I aced all the tests they gave me and, and was in great shape. So I really didn't have to do much of anything. I, I was just, got promoted. And, um, um, I went back to school back in Millington, Tennessee. M- uh, Memphis ... area. And I l- had a, a little apartment in Memphis. I was there for, uh, nine, eight months. And then I, I went out to, uh, San Diego, to Coronado, tried to become a SEAL. That didn't work out. I got a i- infection in my foot. So, uh, ended up getting drummed out, and tried to get back, and it would've been week one instead of week eight, and so forget it.

Doug Shafer

(laughs) Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

Um, I became an air crewman based in Guam, uh, in an EC-121 Super Constellation. We used to be typhoon trackers. We'd fly right into the eye of the typhoon and then find out where in the world we were by looking at the north star with a sextant.

Doug Shafer

You gotta be k-

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh-

Doug Shafer

In a plane?

Tom Rinaldi

Reading off the coordinates.

Doug Shafer

You gotta be kidding me. You f-

Tom Rinaldi

Nope.

Doug Shafer

You guys were flying into typhoons?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, this was before satellite, so that was the, the way to figure out where we were. We'd go in at night, and if it wasn't 100 knots, that didn't count. It was a...

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

...tropical depression. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And I did 30 penetrations. A real live typhoon.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. Can y- uh, y-, uh, I've heard stories about this. I mean, obviously you've lived it 30 times. It just seems like that's a really kind of dangerous, really dangerous thing to do. Or is it not that dangerous, just really hairy?

Tom Rinaldi

It was hairy.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

I'll say that much. Uh, but the one cool thing is I never, ever, ever got airsick.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And I was totally an exception to the rule, 'cause somebody would start and then it would just start moving around and you just, just that aroma was enough for a lot of people.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

How many, how many guys on the v- people on the plane?

Tom Rinaldi

We had two crews of-

Doug Shafer

Just two crews. Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

So there were 24 of us. And so, you would, it, we would fly 18 hours at a time. So it would be nine hours on and nine hours off, or four and a half on, nine hours off, four and a half on. We had a full kitchen, um, bunks. Uh, b- it was living pretty large.

Doug Shafer

Yeah, 'cause these are these big, these are these big, big planes, right?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. Yeah.

Doug Shafer

The s- the su- okay, got it.

Tom Rinaldi

Four engine with tip tanks, and like I say, 18 hours of fuel. So they would kind of pervert us in Vietnam. We'd go flying up to Hai Phong, Hain- Hainan, uh, back and forth there, and monitor all the MiGs and surface to air missiles and boat traffic and you name it. We were, that was our, one of our big responsibilities. I'd go there at least once a month. And typically the end of the month, and then the beginning of the next, and that way we got, uh, hazardous duty pay and, uh, tax free and all this other nice... (laughs)

Doug Shafer

All the nice, uh...

Tom Rinaldi

Accoutrements.

Doug Shafer

But basic- so the Vietnam war was in full swing, but you're a, you were Navy, Navy Air, so you were -

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. But I did spent time on the ground, uh, and in the helicopters.

Doug Shafer

Huh.

Tom Rinaldi

And got spun off to the 101st Airborne. So it was, uh, it wasn't all just flying around. It was, it would be in the water on the ground, you name it. I had a top secret clearance, so I got a map to, to monitor all the, you know, the, the damage in our, on our perimeter. And one thing was, uh, al- they always gave me that lighter, to, you know... (laughs)

Doug Shafer

Huh.

Tom Rinaldi

Anything goes wrong, light the map.

Doug Shafer

Oh, man.

Tom Rinaldi

You know, and then you could do whatever you wanna do about, su- you know, s- defending yourself.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And I'd typically have a m- a marine on either side of me, and they were crackerjack shots. In fact, one time they nailed a guy right up in the tree. I never saw him alive, but I got his AK47 with a scope on it, and everybody thought I was bad.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

I carried that thing wherever I went.

Doug Shafer

Oh, man.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, it w- it was really a, a mean looking machine, I'll say that much. Had a wooden stock with, uh, Vietnamese writing on it, and the works.

Doug Shafer

Wow.

Tom Rinaldi

So, we went back last year, my wife and I, for our...

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

...50th anniversary. My first deployment.

Doug Shafer

Tell me about that. You and Beverly went back, so, 50, so it'd been what, 50 years?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. Almost to the day.

Doug Shafer

Wow.

Tom Rinaldi

April of, uh, 1969 was my first, uh, my first deployment, and, uh, much better reception this time.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

How was that trip? Because I know, I read a couple articles.

Tom Rinaldi

It w-

Doug Shafer

Was it great?

Tom Rinaldi

It was wonderful. I'm really glad we did it last year instead of this year. I, it would've been just impossible.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, but, um, it worked out beautifully. Uh, we took the river cruise up to, uh, into Cambodia, and visited temples and people's homes and the works. It was just, it was phenomenal.

Doug Shafer

Hmm. Nice. Yeah, I'm glad you guys got to do that. You kinda-

Tom Rinaldi

Me too. I, it was a g- a good, uh, you know, memory, um, cleanser, if you will. C- uh, I never had post-traumatic stress disorder. It was the darnedest thing. All my, all my friends got it.

Doug Shafer

Huh.

Tom Rinaldi

But I never had a touch of it. But, uh, I, I had memories, uh, real clear memories of the different places, Da Nang, Chu Lai, Phu Bai, Hue. And, uh, I had to visit each and every one of those and, you know, just kinda wash up the memories. And it's so j- so different 50 years later, it's, it's, it's laughable.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. Why, how come you think you never had the post traumatic thing?

Tom Rinaldi

That is, uh, there's a button or a trigger that snaps, and, uh, I just don't think I have that button or trigger.

Doug Shafer

Huh.

Tom Rinaldi

It, that's all there is to it. I, I've talked to psychologists and different people about it, and, um, th- there's, j- just one of those things.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Well, I'm glad you don't.

Tom Rinaldi

I'm very fortunate in...

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

...that regard, you know, 'cause some of, I, I tried to get a c- few of my friends to come back with me, and there's no way. You know, they're...

Doug Shafer

Interesting.

Tom Rinaldi

...as I say, they, they dream it all the time, that they're still there.

Doug Shafer

Oh.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Oh, man.

Tom Rinaldi

But it was thank you to the GI Bill that I got to, you know, pursue my, my, my career, if you will. I was going to either be a medical doctor or a veterinarian. Took all the prerequisite classes, and I realized that taking wine classes were, uh, as good as anything, uh, to become a, a medical or a veterinary doctor. So, uh, I met a lot of miserable doctors and a lot of happy winemakers...

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

...and decided not to even apply for, for med school. Yeah.

Doug Shafer

'Cause, uh, yeah, I was doing some research on you. So you went to Santa Rosa JC after the navy for a couple years. And then, uh-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

And then moved up to Davis.

Tom Rinaldi

That was a real education, too. I, I had some great classes at, at Santa Rosa JC, and got great s- grades, and so I got to choose whatever college I wanted to go to, and Davis was number one.

Doug Shafer

Nice.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, yeah. I had Maynard Amerine's last class. And, uh, Ann Noble's first class. Uh, they were kind of teaming up, if you will.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

So, it was, that was wonderful. Ralph Kunkee. Um, these-

Doug Shafer

Yeah, I remember Kun-

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, Cornelius Oh. All these guys just are historical figures in my mind.

Doug Shafer

I remember Kunkee. I had Kunkee when I was there. But those other guys...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

...had retired. He was great.

Tom Rinaldi

We used to go out and, uh, have a beer across the street, the Graduate. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

I thought that was cool.

Doug Shafer

The Graduate. I remember that place.

Tom Rinaldi

Sure.

Doug Shafer

Was that, uh, dollar pitcher night for beer on Thursday nights, right?

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

What, was that it, what it was? I remember that.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, what could possibly go wrong?

Doug Shafer

(laughs) Yeah, everything.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. In fact, I have a degree in malting and brewing with Dr. Lewis.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, as well as oenology, viniculture.

Doug Shafer

Who, who else was at, uh, in the oenology program with you? Some of your classmates?

Tom Rinaldi

Mike Martini.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, Bob Levy. Uh, Cathy Corison. Uh, I know I'm gonna leave somebody out. Uh, but one of the Wente boys, and...

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Just, it was a phenomenal... Uh, Tim Mondavi. Yeah. We had a s- uh, spectacular class. I mean, they all knew exactly where they were gonna go work, you know? I-

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

I wasn't sure. But I was very fortunate. I, I was one of, uh, about 20 applying for the, the job at Freemark Abbey. They were hiring a Davis graduate every year. And, um, I was one of the final two. And I'll say Rob Davis was, uh, the other one. And he-

Doug Shafer

Rob Davis who went to Jordan Winery for a long time?

Tom Rinaldi

Correct.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

Right back then, too, back in '76. When I was applying at, uh, Freemark Abbey. M- and so, he had, uh, interviewed with Jerry Luper first, and, um, on his way out, he's going, "Good luck. You'll need it."

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, so I'm interviewing with Jerry. Fortunately, I, I, I was working in the lab at Davis, and s- so I knew all the, the, the programs. Uh, h- how to, you know, check SO2 or volatile acidity or you name it.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. Run a TA. Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

So, I, he couldn't trip me up on any of that stuff. So about 4:30 or quarter to 5, he's going, "Well, it's qu- you know, 4:30. Um, what are you gonna do the rest of the day?" I said, "Uh, I'm gonna go downtown to get a beer." He said, "Oh, c- may I join you?" And I said, "Sure!"

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

So we went downtown in St. Helena and got a beer. I guess at Ray's.

Doug Shafer

Yeah, Ray's!

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, y- (laughs)

Doug Shafer

I remember Ray's.

Tom Rinaldi

And he said, "That's a great answer. You know, all these guys'll say, 'Oh, I got a couple of wines I gotta blend together.' You don't do blending after 4:00 in the afternoon! You know? It's time for a beer, you know?" And we came up with the term, "It takes a lot of good beer to make a great wine."And, uh, that basically got me the job, I think. I don't know. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

'Cause Jerry Luper, now, at that time, this is, you know, a few years before I got into the whole game, but, he was, uh, he, he was, wasn't he g- he was quite the famous winemaker at that time, right? So, it was-

Tom Rinaldi

Indeed, yeah.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

So-

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, he went on to, uh, Europe after, uh, you know, being out in Carneros for a while doing his own thing. Uh, moved out to Europe. And he, I really didn't get a full season with him. He left, uh...

Doug Shafer

Huh.

Tom Rinaldi

...before the season really got into f- bloom. And, uh, Larry Langbehn took over. And h- Larry was a Davis graduate the year before, and I thought, "Hmm. If I play my cards right, maybe I could become a winemaker here, you know?" (laughs)

Doug Shafer

That's right. That's-

Tom Rinaldi

But-

Doug Shafer

That's the era where...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

...people were becoming winemakers, like, instantly out of Davis.

Tom Rinaldi

Something like that, yeah.

Doug Shafer

Almost.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, I g- I got, uh, they promoted me over to, well, uh, p- transferred me over to Rutherford Hill that they'd just acquired.

Oh, I was very frustrated trying to work there in the cellar. And so, after a week, you know, I went to, uh, Phil Baxter, the winemaker, and said, you know, "Hey, I quit." H- he said, "You only been here a week!"

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

I said, "No, this is crazy. I didn't go to Davis to, to, to do this. This is bucket..."

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

"...uh, bucket throwing." And, uh, so he said, "How'd you like to work in the lab?" I said, "Hmm. Okay." And that was the last I ever punched a clock. It was a full time job. I worked in the lab, basically doctoring wines and figuring out what's wrong with this one, well, how are we gonna make it better? And, uh, it was a real education, if you will.

Doug Shafer

Got it.

Tom Rinaldi

So that was a g- great opportunity.

Doug Shafer

So-

Tom Rinaldi

And he introduced me to Ernie Van Asperen, who was...

Doug Shafer

Oh, okay.

Tom Rinaldi

...just starting up Round Hill Winery.

Doug Shafer

All right. I'm gonna st- I, I-

Tom Rinaldi

So I, I was his original.

Doug Shafer

'Cause I wanna get to Ernie, I wanna stop you for a second. So you did an internship at Freemark for what, a year or so, right?

Tom Rinaldi

Just a, the one season.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. One season.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, it was almost a year. It went from, uh, June until bottling time in April, May. So, yeah. About a year.

Doug Shafer

Gotta ask you a question. Was Nico there? Nico Shoch?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. Sure was.

Doug Shafer

Okay. Nico Shoch, who was, 'cause I remember he worked at Freemark under Larry Langbehn.

Tom Rinaldi

Yes. Yep.

Doug Shafer

'Cause Nico, my dad hired Nico as winemaker here at Shafer, when he f- uh, I think he hired him for the 1980 vintage. So, Nico was here...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

...for about three years, and then he moved on and I came in in '83. But, uh, great guy. And, um...

Tom Rinaldi

I agree.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. G- God, boy, strong as an ox, too. Good winemaker.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Um, and so, from there you went... So, Freemark and Rutherford Hill were connected. I remember that. Same ownership. So, they moved you over to Free- to Rutherford Hill with Phil Baxter, he was the winemaker.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

So, uh, here's another question for you. Were you there during the '79 harvest?

Tom Rinaldi

Yes.

Doug Shafer

(laughs) 'Cause the seventy-

Tom Rinaldi

Disaster.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. That was, I can't, well, I wasn't here. I can't remember the details. But I do know that dad picked his grapes really late and they were super, super ripe.

Tom Rinaldi

Y- you know-

Doug Shafer

Uh, I, I-

Tom Rinaldi

I was, by then, I, that was my second year at Duckhorn, so...

Doug Shafer

Oh, you were gone. Oh.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

See, y- .

Tom Rinaldi

'Cause, uh, '78... One sec. I had just...

Doug Shafer

Well, that's right. That's right.

Tom Rinaldi

...kinda mixing them up.

Doug Shafer

That's right.

Tom Rinaldi

'Cause, uh, yeah. I would've been there for just, uh, '76, '77 harvest. Uh...

Doug Shafer

Got it. Okay. 'Cause-

Tom Rinaldi

And then, yeah.

Doug Shafer

Okay. Sorry about that.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, '78, '79. '79, we didn't make a Cabernet that year.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Basically just gave it up. Uh, I remember being in a vineyard with my, my wife, Beverly, uh, she was my girlfriend at the time, but, um, we were, we were watching them pick these, uh, grapes out in, uh, uh, Georges three in Rutherford, and they're pouring them into this gondola and you couldn't see the grapes. There was just so much liquid.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

We followed them to BV, and they tipped the gondola into the, this trough, and the trough just bled out. They let all the liquid go.

Doug Shafer

Oh.

Tom Rinaldi

And then they j- saved the grapes and put them into a destemmer and up into into the tanks. And it was the darnedest thing, watching that. And so, we, we said, now, I got the day off today, so let's, let's go downtown, get some, you know, steaks and barbecue them. And we go to Safeway, and we're crunching along the aisles. It's the darnedest thing. We're, we're crunching along and it's bags and bags of sugar these guys are carrying.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

A- and I asked the manager, I said, "What's going on with the sugar?" And he says, "I guess they're drinking a lot of coffee this year." You know -

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

"Oh, sure."

Doug Shafer

So I wasn't around for the '79 harvest. So you're telling me it was probably a lot of rain and couldn't get ripeness, is what you're telling me.

Tom Rinaldi

Exactly correct.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

It was the, the only disaster vintage I can recall in, you know, 45 vintages. So, yeah.

Doug Shafer

Interesting. And here's my, what dad told me about our '79, 'cause we didn't have a winery. He was custom crushing, he custom crushed it up at, uh, Rutherford Hill with Phil Baxter. And-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

I, this was Hillside stuff. Early years for dad. And our Hillside stuff comes in early, and for some reason, it must have been b- way before the rains, 'cause he couldn't, he couldn't get pickers and it was a bit of a hot spell, and he brought the stuff in at 25 or 26 bricks. And Baxter goes, "Well, we're gonna have to take care of that." So, the opposite situation happened.

Tom Rinaldi

Wow.

Doug Shafer

Instead of add- instead of adding sugar, they add a little, little, uh, H2O to get that sugar back down. So, interesting.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

'Cause I didn't, I didn't know the rest of the harvest was such a d- was such a mess with the rain and cold weather.

Tom Rinaldi

It was. We did bring in a little bit of Cabernet from up on Howell Mountain, uh, but most, most of what we brought in was Merlot, and that was, uh, uh, spared the w- the weather. It was, you know, like, y- yeah. Like, y- you heard, it was a heat s- heat wave before...

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

...the rain came. And when the rain came, it, it really didn't let up. It, it just went all the way through the rest of the time. So, the people who were picking then, th- they tried everything. They tried helicopters with, uh, w- leaf blowers, you name it, to try to just get rid of the water. Uh, it, it was just basically a disaster.

Doug Shafer

Oh, man. And you mentioned Beverly. So you guys were dating? How'd you guys meet?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. We met in Calistoga, believe it or not. I was sitting down with Ben Falk and Jon Axehelm and having a, we had two or three bottles of wine open at the table, and, uh, we're tasting them. And, uh, and she was walking by and they're tapping on the window. They knew her.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

So she came in, uh, in our old spot, you know, the Calistoga Inn. And sat down and drinking some wine with us, you know? And all of a sudden we're playing footsie under the table...

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

...and I got her phone number, and... But we never did hook up. It was the darnedest thing. We met again in, uh, Las Vegas for one of those oenology conventions, and, uh, put two and two together. Eventually I got ahold of her and we went out on a date to the Cameo to see the Godfather, part one and two.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And missed part of the beginning, so we had to go back again (laughs) the next day. I had a motorcycle back then, uh, so that was my, my transportation. And, hmm, pretty much got married in nineteen-sev- uh, b- b- '81.

Doug Shafer

Okay. Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Mother's Day.

Doug Shafer

Beautiful.

Tom Rinaldi

And, um, yeah. That was the last of the motorcycle days. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

(laughs) So, um, and I, I interrupted you earlier. You mentioned, uh, Ernie Van Asperen. So, you met, you met him when you were up at, uh, Rutherford Hill?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. We actually had lunch together, d- Phil wanted m- to introduce, uh, Ernie to me, and, um, Ernie had a, uh, a wine in a decanter.

Doug Shafer

Uh-huh.

Tom Rinaldi

And he's pouring it for me, and he, he wants to know, "What do you think of this wine?" And I g- I'm smelling it, and just going, "I think I know this wine. Uh, is this Silver Oak?" And he's g- he's looking around like, like I got a tip from the maitre d' or something, you know?

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And he goes, "Yeah." H- I go, "Yeah, I think this is '70, '72, uh, '72, uh, Silver Oak." Uh, 'cause we had made that at fr- Franciscan, and I had put in a spell there.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, tasted out of the barrel a few times. And it had that distinctive bread character.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

So, he was blown away. Uh, I became this palate, if you will.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, yeah. There, so, uh, we, we'd go up to, uh, um, Healdsberg and different wineries and I'd get to meet all the rock stars up there, um, and taste through the wines that were available in bulk. And the ones I, I liked, I'd keep close to me, and the ones I didn't like, I'd push away. So it would be, A, E, and F I liked. And so, he would shoo me out of the room, let me go take a tour of the facility while he did a, a negotiation with the winemakers.

Doug Shafer

Huh.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, come up with a price, and that's, that was the beginning of Round Hill. We, we did a '74 Cabernet to die for. It was just wonderful. And we were able to sell it for a song, too, and still make money.

Doug Shafer

So, Round Hill, Ernie Van Asperen started Round Hill, and his other career, that they, I think went on for the whole time, was he had wine stores, right? Um -

Tom Rinaldi

Yes. Ernie's.

Doug Shafer

Call, called Ernie's.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

And a n- a number of them, as I remember.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. Y- yeah. I got to work in most of them, in fact all of them. Uh, where was one, down in San Bruno, w- uh, Redwood City, up in, uh, uh, San Francisco, and up here, in St. Helena.

Doug Shafer

That's right. I remember that.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, right there on Inglewood.

Doug Shafer

And he, but then, so, when he started Round Hill, he was basically, help me with this one. He was buying bulk wine and bottling it under the Round Hill label, or was he crushing grapes also?

Tom Rinaldi

No. No grapes.

Doug Shafer

Interesting.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, we would just get bulk. Yeah. In fact, uh, th- it was out at Lodi Lane, um, the, oh god. Marian Green's, um, h- home right next door, and there was a w- a, basically a warehouse, and it w- we, we bottled there.

Doug Shafer

So he was, like, the first Negociant w- guy, in a way.

Tom Rinaldi

Correct.

Doug Shafer

Or one of th-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

One of the early, for sure.

Doug Shafer

He's, okay. It was the Round Hi- and so, so you star- at that point, you're working with him. Or you help found that whole winery? Is that what you do?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Wow.

Tom Rinaldi

I was original winemaker, so, um, I'd, I'd make the blending decisions and, uh, you know, he'd come up with basically the quantities, and, um, that was it, that was that. Uh, Charlie Abella was my right hand man. He was a very sharp guy.

Doug Shafer

I, I was gonna ask you about Charlie, 'cause I remember-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Dad, Dad and, Dad loved Charlie, and I met him a couple times.

Tom Rinaldi

He was a great guy.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

Oh my god. He was just wonderful.

Doug Shafer

Wow.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, he was one of my best men at, uh, my wedding. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

Um...

Tom Rinaldi

Along with Bob Levy. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

And I remember, the only time I was at Round Hill, I was, uh, that's where I met Charlie Abella, I met Doug Manning. It was Christmas time. I was home from Davis, and Dad-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

It was, it was the Christmas of '78. So, you weren't there, but, um-

Tom Rinaldi

Right.

Doug Shafer

Dad had, he was aging a '78 Cab, first wine he made. It was, uh, crushed it at Markham, they made it at Round Hill, 'cause he knew Ernie and Charlie.

Tom Rinaldi

Sure.

Doug Shafer

So, it was, like, a custom crush. 1000 cases. So, um, he said, "Well, I'm going up to rack my wine." I'm home from Davis. I said, "Okay." He goes, "Come along." So I'm up there learning how to wash barrels with Charlie Abella and Doug Manning. And then r- um, it was lunch break. We're sitting down having some sandwiches, and these guys pulled some of the, the '78 Cab, the, um, Shafer, a- out of the tank that we were racking to, just to have with lunch. And, and you know, I d- I didn't know if it was good or not. And, um, I remember Doug Manning going, "This is really good." (laughs) So...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

And, uh, that was my first, uh, experience with our '78 Cab. And it was like, I didn't know what was going on. I mean, we, you know...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

...went back to barrels and went back to school. So that was the, the birth of that. How funny.

Tom Rinaldi

That really put Shafer on the map, too. That, that wine was spectacular. There's no question about it. We, we rated it as flawless at, uh, up there in Calistoga.

Doug Shafer

Well, thank you. But, uh, speaking of '78, so how did you get from Round Hill to Duckhorn?

Tom Rinaldi

The darnedest thing. Uh, I, I was good friends with, uh, v- Ric Forman and with Phil Baxter and w- let's see. Someone else who Dan Duckhorn was talking to, saying you, he needed a winemaker, and they all mentioned my name.

Doug Shafer

Huh.

Tom Rinaldi

So, he wanted to, to, to meet with me, and I happened to be going by the winery on my motorcycle, and I pull up, 'cause he's out there working in, uh, some trees. And so, we had a little discussion and, uh, the funniest thing is that he, I said, "Well, you know, I'll, I'll consult for you," he goes, "Consult? Hell! I want somebody to make the wine!" You know? (laughs)

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

So, okay. So I got the job on the spot. And, uh, that was, uh, June of '78. There really wasn't a facility there. He has just bought a, a press and a couple of tanks and, you know, just trying to make something happen. And we, we bought a, a, a destemmer and, and went from there. I mean, it was a little basket press. I still have a picture of myself and s- you know, kneeling down, taking a, a sample out of the, out of this little press. But, uh well, it was an interesting beginning. Fortunately, it was 1978, and '76 was hot, er, hot, awful, dry drought.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

'77, same thing.

Doug Shafer

Mm-hmm (affirmative).

Tom Rinaldi

'78 was a perfect vintage. And then of course '79 was the disas- disaster.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, we, fortunately, my, my good friend Ric Forman turned us on to Three Palms. He didn't have to do that by any stretch of the imagination. He was winemaker at Sterling. And we had no intention of making a Merlot. Uh, "Merlot? You know, what?" And so, we brought it in anyway, and it was knockout. Um, and, and I didn't know the rules at the time. I shoulda known.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

But I put in 15 percent Beatty Howell Mountain Cabernet into it.

Doug Shafer

Oh.

Tom Rinaldi

We had a bottle, yeah, and a councilor, you know, our council's going, uh, "So, Tom, what else is in there?" I go, "Well, I got 15 percent Beatty Howell Mountain Cabernet," and he goes, "No, you, come on."

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And I go, "No, seriously." He goes, "No."

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And I, uh, so, he opens up chapter and verse, there it is. 95 percent, same as vintage. Uh oh. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

So, we gotta use up by BATF. Uh, one time only. And, uh, so we got away with it. And thank goodness, 'cause to th- to this day, that wine is still alive and well.

Doug Shafer

It's a gorgeous wine. It was 15 percent, it was Merlot, or Cab?

Tom Rinaldi

Cabernet, 15 percent.

Doug Shafer

But it was a-

Tom Rinaldi

And the rest of it was Merlot Three Palms.

Doug Shafer

But it was a different vintage? Or same vintage?

Tom Rinaldi

Same vintage.

Doug Shafer

Got it. Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Oh.

Tom Rinaldi

If it says Three Palms Vineyard, it, well, it, just like Hillside select-

Doug Shafer

Oh, it's gotta be 95 percent. That's right.

Tom Rinaldi

Correct.

Doug Shafer

Got it.

Tom Rinaldi

Whoops.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

So, so Ric Forman, who was winemaker at the time at Sterling, and he was a, he was a stud winemaker in those days. He was the guy, one of the guys. And, um...

Tom Rinaldi

Absolutely.

Doug Shafer

And, uh, they were, I remember Sterling had a Three Palms Vineyard Merlot, I think, 'cause...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

And so, he turned you guys onto that. So, I, for some reason I thought D- Dan was crazy about Merlot and really wanted to do it. So that wasn't the case?

Tom Rinaldi

He became crazy about it, I'll say that much. And he wanted to do it for sure, 'cause he and Ric did get to travel tog- to, to France together.

Doug Shafer

Okay 'cause it, uh, a lot of folks might not know, Merlot back in late '70s, very few people if anyone made a varietal Merlot. Merlot was used mostly for blending. So I can remember I was working at Lake Spring with Randy Mason. That was '81, '82, and they were starting to make a Merlot, but it was still kinda new. So you guys, you know, were trailblazers, and that first wine, '78 Merlot, was, from Duckhorn, was absolutely amazing. And it had 15 percent Cab. That's good to know. (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

Whoopsie!

Doug Shafer

A minute ago.

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

I love it.

Tom Rinaldi

That make all the difference in the world, too. I think if it were, been 100 percent, uh, Merlot, it would've been a head scratcher. And to this day they don't make 100 percent Merlot out of there. It's, uh, it's got all five varietals growing in the vineyard.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And it's all owned by Duckhorn now.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

I kinda made a little joke a while back to, that I wanted to get some of the grapes, and (laughs) they kinda look at me y- dumbfounded.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

But, um, uh, yeah. That, I made it at Provenance, as a matter of fact, I was c- making a Three Palms Merlot and a Three Palms Cabernet. I had access to the fruit. But then Diageo just chickened out from the prices and they let it go.

Doug Shafer

How big, how big a vineyard is it? How many acres?

Tom Rinaldi

80.

Doug Shafer

80. Okay. I didn't realize...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

...it was that big. Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

It's all rock, too.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

But there's, fortunately there's water, and, uh, yeah. In fact, uh, to plant it, they were using fire hoses to blast a hole into the rock.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

Um, and then filling it up with sand and, and, and, and real dirt. And, and a, a- and a root stock.

Doug Shafer

Interesting. Interesting. So...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

So, Duckhorn, f- first release was a seventy- I think that was the first release from Duckhorn, it was '78 Merlot.

Tom Rinaldi

Correct.

Doug Shafer

Released in '81, probably, thereabouts. And, uh, was that the only wine from Duckhorn in the beginning? Was there Cabernet, too?

Tom Rinaldi

No. We made a Cabernet as well.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

The Cabernet was, uh, very nice. V- it was, uh, it was from, uh, um, Spottswoode Vineyard. And also, uh, down in your area. I can't remember his name. Dick.

Doug Shafer

Uh, S- Steltzner. Steltzner.

Tom Rinaldi

Dick Steltzner. Correct.

Doug Shafer

Right. Mm-hmm (affirmative).

Tom Rinaldi

Thank you.

Doug Shafer

You bet.

Tom Rinaldi

And, that was, uh, that was fascinating stuff. We only sold it for $10.50, but we went crazy with the Merlot and jacked it all the way up to $12.50.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

S- it was so funny, because there'd be some people who'd say, "Oh, I'm not gonna b- I don't know, my husband would never drink Merlot." I said, "Well, don't tell him it's Merlot." And especially after that Sideways movie came out, um, and, you know, they'd come back and just say, "You're right. He loves it." You know? (laughs) You didn't tell him it was Merlot.

Doug Shafer

Well, I was gonna ask you about that, because y- you know, you were really on the front lines in the beginning. You know, a t- a totally kind of unknown varietal by itself, Merlot, you know, bursts on the scene, and, you know, kinda meanders around in the '80s. People more familiar with it. And then the '90s, it just goes nuts. Rock star. You know, and then all of a sudden becoming kind of a, you know, a punchline from a, from a movie. I mean, uh...

Tom Rinaldi

Well, what had happened...

Doug Shafer

What's your take on that?

Tom Rinaldi

...was that Merlot was already on the ropes. They were making it down in, uh, M- Monterrey, and Lodi, and...calling it Merlot, and it was Blanc.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, it was, really it was bringing the name down. There was just too much of it, and it was growing in the wrong spots. Uh, it needs good drainage. If you don't have good drainage, you don't really have Merlot.

Doug Shafer

Mm-hmm (affirmative).

Tom Rinaldi

And so, it was getting kinda beat up as a varietal. M- we fortunately had a good reputation, a good name, and we never just bottled something just to call it Merlot. So, that, that was a crucial part of our success during that, that time where it really was a, kind of a joke, if you will. You couldn't even give the stuff away in Los Angeles.

But the, the punchline in there was not supposed to really be, uh, taken seriously. Um, I mean, you wouldn't want that guy Miles to be your, your, uh, your, maitre d'. (laughs) So, he's drinking out of the spit bucket, remember?

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

So, um, yeah. So, uh, it, it was not meant to be serious, but it, it was taken seriously. You know? "None of that blanking Merlot." And, uh...

Doug Shafer

Yeah, I, I remember hearing the story that it was l- uh, it was, uh, just a, it was like they were doing 10 or 12 takes and it was the last shot of the night and they were all hungry, so he was just kinda letting loose with that, ripped on, ripped with that line.

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

And then they c- they took it back in the editing and kept it, which was...

Tom Rinaldi

Yep.

Doug Shafer

...unfortunate, 'cause it kinda...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

...hurt sales for a lot of people. But...

Tom Rinaldi

Ah, it's all right.

Doug Shafer

...I, I think in the long run it's, it's done good things for Merlot, because, uh, um, all the folks that were making Merlot maybe not as good as it should be kind of, a lot of the Negociant guys went away, stopped making it.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. Yeah.

Doug Shafer

They started making, they started making Pinot Noir. And, uh, so now Mer- you know, y-

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

A f- if you see a varietal Merlot out there, chances are it's gonna be pretty darn good, because if it's not, you know, th- it doesn't have a chance to start, it doesn't have to a chance to beg- be- to begin with. So, um, it'll, it's there.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, I've taken it seriously all my, my career.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, you know, we're making a Pellet Estate Merlot, and it's, it's good enough it stands on its own. It don't need to add anything to it. Sometimes I will add some, uh, Cabernet Sauvignon, but it's a, uh, estate out there on the base of Spring Mountain. That stuff, just a knockout.

Doug Shafer

Hmm.

Tom Rinaldi

I'm, I'm still enjoying it, you know. Still enjoying making Merlot.

Doug Shafer

Good. Good. So, 22 years at Duckhorn. How... And it was a great, great run. Why'd, why'd it work so well? What was, what worked? What was the trick at Duckhorn? 'Cause it's a wonderful place.

Tom Rinaldi

Well, I, I would say we, we focused on quality, not quantity. Um, and you know, I w- I was meticulous on, on making sure that we didn't bottle anything that we weren't gonna be proud of. That's why we came up with, you know, names like Decoy and Migration and so forth. These were second labels, and, uh, weren't supposed to shine like the Duckhorn, uh, lo- m- n- the m- uh, our moniker, you know.

Doug Shafer

Mm-hmm (affirmative).

Tom Rinaldi

Our, our, our, our home base. Uh, so, th- that was very important, uh, and we had a good run of vineyards and meticulous, uh, management. Um, very, very pleased with the, the Madrigal, uh, connection we had, and, uh, Jess Madrigal in particular. Uh, they were, they were meticulous on making sure that we got all the quality we could.

Doug Shafer

And that's, that's Madrigal, that's Jess Madrigal and t- their, their, uh, vineyard. Vineyard management company.

Tom Rinaldi

That's right.

Doug Shafer

Right. So they take care of you guys.

Tom Rinaldi

And I'm still up there making wine. (laughs).

Doug Shafer

Wow.

Tom Rinaldi

That's my, that's my go to place for, for, uh, Pellet, for my own, and yeah. We're starting a new wine company, uh, called Double Plus. We'll have Sauvignon Blanc and cabernet, uh, coming in.

Doug Shafer

Cool. So, that's-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, I agree.

Doug Shafer

Th- that's your own, that's your own, uh, your own deal coming up.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, and w- we're a legal entity.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs) I do a lot of things under the radar, you know, for family and friends, but, uh, this one's gonna be a legal entity.

Doug Shafer

Cool. So, after Duckhorn you made a move. Tell me about that one.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. I got the opportunity to, to go to Hewitt w- uh, d- Hewitt Vineyard, and, and use Bill Hewitt's name. Uh, Mr. Hewitt had passed away, and the opportunity came up, uh, and they were really trying to get me to, to interview with this Tom Selfridge guy, and so I finally said, "Look, you know, we'll have lunch together in, in Yountville. I don't wanna do it in St. Helena, have people talking and wondering." So we had lunch and, uh, we go out to the vineyard after lunch, and it's just c- phenomenal. Phenomenal.

Doug Shafer

Mm-hmm (affirmative).

Tom Rinaldi

And he's got me up at the house, he's pointing around to the vineyard, and he said, "All of this would be yours." You know, it's like the devil...

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

...tempting Jesus. And, uh...

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And I'm, I'm looking at it, I s- I said, "Well, you know what, tell you the truth, um, I'm not, I'm not even flying the plane anymore. I'm, I'm on autopilot at, at Duckhorn."

Doug Shafer

Hmm.

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, we'd acquired Goldeneye. W- we had Paraduxx. We had all these facilities and winemakers, and I'm just basically looking over their shoulder, k- kind of steering them around a little bit, but I wasn't really flying the plane.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And so, this would've been an opportunity to start all over again, and, uh, with this... So I said, "Throw my na- my, my hat into the ring," and he said, "Well, you're the only hat." (laughs)

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

So, I said, "Let's wait till after the wine auction in, uh, 2000 till we make any kind of a mention of it." But I had already hinted to Dan and Margaret that I was leaving, and they were breaking up, too. So, um, they never got it until, you know, basically the wine auction. And I mentioned it to Mike Thompson, our congressman, and he kinda like, his jaw drops. He goes, "You can't leave Duckhorn! You are Duckhorn!" (laughs)

Doug Shafer

(laughs) Well-

Tom Rinaldi

And I, it was a great opportunity to work with the Hewitt fruit, and, and then I didn't realize it, but Provenance was there, too. We had a huge contract with Andy Beckstoffer bringing in Merlot and cabernet from all around the valley.

Doug Shafer

Okay. Interesting. No, I remember when that news broke that you were leaving Duckhorn, and we were all, um, yeah. 'Cause Rinaldi is Duckhorn. Um...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

But, uh, good for you. That takes a lot of guts, and, uh, how fun to get back in the... What was it like to get back in the driver's seat?

Tom Rinaldi

Oh, it was, you know, to tell you the truth, we, the first couple of years were, I wasn't really in the driver's seat. Uh, we were doing custom crushing. Our first year was at Cardinale and that was 2000, and then 2001, we were at Andretti and Laird.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And then by 2002, we acquired that building that became, uh, it was Beaucanon. It became Provenance. And, uh, A- August of 2002, we had purchased it and moved in, and we did the whole harvest there. It was the darnedest thing. It was exciting.

Doug Shafer

Hmm.

Tom Rinaldi

That became very exciting. Yeah. Interesting to look back, too, 'cause I've been replaced I think five times now.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

Since I left in November of 2014. And, um, the same thing happened at Duckhorn. Um...

Doug Shafer

Yeah, there's been a few. S-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. Tony Biagi didn't take over like I thought he would. Uh, Mark Beringer did.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And Mark's over at Beringer now. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

He's at Beringer, right.

Tom Rinaldi

Where he, uh, belongs.

Doug Shafer

I know.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

So, Provenance for 14 years. Another great run. Good for you.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, indeed.

Doug Shafer

And, uh, and Hewitt. And I think you, you'd got, Cab got, uh, in the top ten Spectators one year, back in '13.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, it was number four.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

In the world, and, uh, number one Cabernet. And, uh, that was cool. Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

That was a 2010 vintage.

Doug Shafer

Which is a -

Tom Rinaldi

We made a Double Plus that year that was even higher scoring, but there wasn't enough quantity to, to, uh, to, uh, get that kind of score.

Doug Shafer

Aren't you am- you know, 2010, aren't you amazed how good the 2010s are? Because at the time, it was a really tough harvest. I remember just being, "Aw," you know, I just, the weather wasn't cooperating. We couldn't, ripeness was, uh, there, it wasn't there. I mean, I just remember Elias and I were pulling our hair out, and then the t- and then the, you know, a year and a half later you're bottling these wines, going, "God, these are beautiful." So-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. Yeah.

Doug Shafer

You just never know. Kinda funny.

Tom Rinaldi

Really. There was something about how the, the wines got along with the barrels, I think, that year. Uh, d- that was...

Doug Shafer

Hmm.

Tom Rinaldi

...a crucial part. We're really getting meticulous about the barrel selection, the toasting, the works. And, and that's a crucial ingredient. It, it's much more important than most people would ever imagine. And, um, uh, uh, I think they played well together that, that vintage.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. I know I, yeah. I spent a lot of time with, uh, coopers, coopers and selection, and um, but t-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah, in retrospect...

Doug Shafer

That technol- technology's gotten -

Tom Rinaldi

...the '11 and the, and even the '08, and, uh, were, those were more difficult...

Doug Shafer

Mm-hmm (affirmative).

Tom Rinaldi

...vintages to, to, you know, put together than the, than the '10.

Doug Shafer

Right. Um, so after '14, you retired. So, how's retirement going?

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

It's fun. Honest to god, I, you know, um, I don't have...

Doug Shafer

No, I mean-

Tom Rinaldi

...to get out of bed in the morning if I don't wanna. You know? It's just, uh...

Doug Shafer

You're-

Tom Rinaldi

It, it's been a good ride.

Doug Shafer

You're not retired.

Tom Rinaldi

And I'm up in Washington...

Doug Shafer

You, you're not retired.

Tom Rinaldi

Y- I know.

Doug Shafer

You're busy.

Tom Rinaldi

I know.

Doug Shafer

Tell me, so, tell m- I wanna hear, I wanna hear about everything. So, Washington? What else?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. I'm, uh, with, uh, Stan Keeterman, our gas guy. Uh, got a beautiful vineyard across from, uh, Oakville Crossroad.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, and then I'm doing the Pellet Estate, and, um, p- oh, um, Stout Family Vineyards, too.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

We just bottled a nice Sauvignon Blanc. Um, and, nyeh, this, uh, this new one, the Alpha Omega, uh, what am I saying. Uh, Double Plus.

Doug Shafer

Double Plus.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

And, uh...

So, uh, consulting. Besides not having to get out of bed at any particular time, what else do you like about it?

Tom Rinaldi

Well, I, I make the f- the final decisions for blending. I, that's, that's a crucial part in my life anyway. Uh, so that, that one is, is something I've been very blessed, uh, to, to have the ability to, to separate what I th- I'm convinced is gonna be very popular from something that probably won't work out. And, uh, so it, it, that part is crucial. Um, I do that every year, uh, up in Washington. I'll, I'll mark the barrels, uh, with these different s- emblems or symbols.

Doug Shafer

Mm-hmm (affirmative). Right.

Tom Rinaldi

And, um, and then come back, uh, a- and see how they get together. How they blend together. And then we'll c- come back a month later and do the final, final blends. And, um, that's, that's my call. Uh, they, they all let me do as I wish.

Doug Shafer

Huh.

Tom Rinaldi

I'm a partner as well as their consulting winemaker.

Doug Shafer

That's, that's-

Tom Rinaldi

And, it-

Doug Shafer

That's super.

Tom Rinaldi

It's been very successful.

Doug Shafer

That's super.

Tom Rinaldi

In fact, I just got a couple of cases and there's two more on their way of the Rosé. We, we finished it out. It's my summer wine. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

Nice.

Tom Rinaldi

I just love it. Got the twist off, and it's Syrah and Grenache. And, uh, it's the bleed. And, uh, it's salmon color perfect. It's wonderful.

Doug Shafer

Well, good. So, when I'm, I'm, I'm buzzing home on Pratt Avenue, one of these evenings, I'll stop by. 'Cause, uh...

Tom Rinaldi

I'll have one chilled for you, ready to go. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

You got it. 'Cause you're, I pass your house, you're my short cut. And I'm trying to keep the s-

Tom Rinaldi

Good show.

Doug Shafer

I'm trying to keep the speed fairly down. I'm working on it.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

I'm working on it. Um...

Tom Rinaldi

It's 35.

Doug Shafer

I know.

Tom Rinaldi

And we wanted to make it 25, like the rest of town, but that's all right.

Doug Shafer

Uh, y-

Tom Rinaldi

You know, people still go 50.

Doug Shafer

Yeah. It's rural. Come on. We're country folks.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Um, but I gotta ask you about something else. Besides wine and your passion for wine, you are probably the most famous cyclist in the Napa Valley. You are... When did you start, when did this passion start? All you do is ride your bike.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. It, it was d- I would have to say it was probably during the Davis days. Um, it was after I had, uh, I, I c- say my seventh knee operation.

Doug Shafer

Oh. (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, believe it or not. And, uh, I just took on the bicycle as a, a way I might, my p- the doctor did the, oh, he did a cadaver, replacement for my ligaments, and, uh, did a micro-fracturing of my kneecap.

Doug Shafer

Hmm.

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, he, you know, I told him I'm sick and tired of going to physiotherapy, and he said, "Well, just ride your bicycle." And you g- and I go, "Well, Doc, you know, either I'm riding up and down the highway with the drunks or I'm up in some serious hills." "Yeah, well, go up in the serious hills."

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

I go, "Well, aren't you worried that I'll overdo it?" And he goes, "No. You can't overdo it." "Oh yeah?" And so that was like a challenge.

Doug Shafer

Okay. (laughs) Well, because-

Tom Rinaldi

Uh, it really got into my, my blood, no question about it.

Doug Shafer

Well, it is.

Tom Rinaldi

I, I, I've done 10 death rides, and that's-

Doug Shafer

What's, what's a death ride?

Tom Rinaldi

Out of Markleeville.

Doug Shafer

What's a-

Tom Rinaldi

It's a, you v- go over Monitor Pass down into Nevada, back over Monitor Pass and then into Hope Valley, and then up, uh, Ebbetts Pass, and then down, and then b- uh, to Strawberry and then back around, up and down, and then you do Carson Pass up to the top and back down. And it's, uh...

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

...130 miles and 16,000 feet of climbing and it's just nuts.

Doug Shafer

You done 10 of those?

Tom Rinaldi

10 of them.

Doug Shafer

How long's-

Tom Rinaldi

One more, and-

Doug Shafer

How long's it take to, how long's it take to do that?

Tom Rinaldi

Best time is about nine hours.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And typically closer to 10.

Doug Shafer

Oh, man. You know, uh, you know, I started riding. I remember I called you a few years ago, 'cause I was saying, you know, "How do you wear these bike pants?" Instead of laughing at me, you laughed with me. I really appreciate that, by the way, Tom.

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

I've never thanked you for that. Most people would've said, "Don't you know what you're talking about, Shafer?" You were like, "Shafer, here's what you do. You, just the pa- ba-ba-ba-ba-bum," you were great. Um...

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

But I remember talking to guys early on when I was, uh, I'd be really proud 'cause I rode to Calistoga and back and, you know, averaged, you know, 15 miles per hour. And somebody said, I don't think it was you, but they said, "Well, have you, have you gone up over into Pope Valley?" I said, "No." They said, "Why not?" I go, "Well, there's a real big hill there." (laughs) And they said w- (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

They said, "Well, for the good riding, you gotta get, you gotta climb one of these hills and get out into the..."

Tom Rinaldi

It-

Doug Shafer

"...uh, wilderness out there."

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

But I do wanna ask you one question about cycling, because I heard a story that you did a midnight ride to Tahoe once. Is that true?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. It was-

Doug Shafer

(laughs) Tell me that one.

Tom Rinaldi

We, it was a full moon, and we went to Ana's Cantina and had a beer, uh, Dave Smith, had a beer, I had a beer, a Guinness.

Doug Shafer

Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

And Lorelai, uh...

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

Tuttle had a diet coke.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

And we got on our bicycles and went down to the trail and then down to 128 and up to Lake Hennessey and then to Lake Berryessa and kept going.

Doug Shafer

D- was that the plan, or did just, you got up there and just-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Okay, that was the plan. You just... (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

We got to, 'cause Dave has a, a, a nice little home up in Tahoe, uh, north shore, as well as down here in, uh, Napa Valley. And he had a place in Costa Rica, too.

Doug Shafer

So you rode to-

Tom Rinaldi

That being said, um, uh-

Doug Shafer

You rode the d- all, you rode all night long in the full moon, to t- Lake Tahoe?

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. And then, sunrise, uh, in, uh, Grass Valley area.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

And then, uh, the climb up to Truckee. And we got to Truckee and we're having a big breakfast.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And coffee and, you know, just thinking, "Well, this is good enough. Let's, let's get a ride the way back."

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, "Nah. Let's go."

Doug Shafer

No. You rode-

Tom Rinaldi

So we just kept going.

Doug Shafer

You rode... Oh, you-

Tom Rinaldi

So, we got to, uh, sh- north shore, 198 miles.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

And I'm looking at the odometer, and it just clicked over to 199, and I'm thinking, "I oughta go round the block- ah, forget about it." I mean...

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

I don't have to do 200, after-

Doug Shafer

Ah.

Tom Rinaldi

After all.

Doug Shafer

That's a, how long a, how long did that one take? How many hours?

Tom Rinaldi

That was, we got in about 1:00 in the afternoon.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

So, we left at 10:30, and that, yeah. It was 14 hours.

Doug Shafer

Ah. You're crazy.

Tom Rinaldi

15 hours. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

You're crazy. I love you. I love you.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. We had a masseuse waiting for us too. We, uh, each of us got a nice massage afterward.

Doug Shafer

You need that. You need that.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

So, tell me-

Tom Rinaldi

And a lot of pizza.

Doug Shafer

Tell me about Double Plus. Are, can people buy these wines yet? Are they out?

Tom Rinaldi

No, no, not yet.

Doug Shafer

Okay.

Tom Rinaldi

We, we haven't even, uh, we haven't even h- picked our first grape yet.

Doug Shafer

Okay. Okay. So, it's coming.

Tom Rinaldi

So, this is something for the future.

Doug Shafer

Tell me about the name. What's the name mean?

Tom Rinaldi

Well, it's my symbol for, when I'm going to barrels, and I, I, I'll give them a check if, if that's good enough, a plus if it's really nice, or a minus if I don't think it's all that good, or w- god forbid, X, you know, if it's got brettanomyces or some flaw.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

I'll give it an X. But every now and then I'll find one, ooh. Give it an H, I call it. A two plus.

Doug Shafer

A Double Plus. Oh, this is-

Tom Rinaldi

And, uh, we tried to call our high end, um, Hewitt, Ambassador, 'cause he was the ambassador to Jamaica once he retired as, uh, John Deere's, uh, President and CEO.

Doug Shafer

(laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

So, we wanted to call it Ambassador, but that's the wine I'm working with in, in Washington. We have to call it Ambassador Wine of Washington, because there's an Ambassador Vineyard that, uh, Zellerbach owns in Sonoma County. So, to make sure there's no confusion there. So, th- the company would not allow us to use, uh, the Ambassador, uh, as, uh, you know, an indication of high end.

Doug Shafer

Right.

Tom Rinaldi

So I said, "How about Double Plus?" And boom, it stuck. Yeah, there we go.

Doug Shafer

You know...

Tom Rinaldi

But they never trademarked it.

Doug Shafer

Oh, you gotta trademark it. And I got to-

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah!

Doug Shafer

I'll tell you why you gotta trademark, because, um, I do something that no one knows about except Elias. So, when we're tasting blends, you know, blind- we got five or six wines in front of us. Or even, uh, even like a, if we're tasting competition. Um, you know, I don't get into too many, you know, adjectives, it's just mostly I'm just like, you know, quality of nose. What's the aroma like? What's the mouth like? You know, just nose and mouth, nose and mouth.

Tom Rinaldi

Sure.

Doug Shafer

And I rank them. And I use, uh, little symbols (laughs) and there's, starting at the bottom is two, two negatives, two minus sign like an equals sign.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

Next better would be just one minus sign. Uh, okay would just be, like, a check. I might use a check...

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

...or I might just use the word okay.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

If I like it, I give it a plus, whether it's nose or mouth, and if I really like it, I give it two pluses. (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

There you go.

Doug Shafer

I got the same thing. Tommy, I'm doing the same thing!

Tom Rinaldi

Bingo. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

All right. You can give me, I, I can work for you. I'll consult with you.

Tom Rinaldi

There you go.

Doug Shafer

You do the final blends, I'll just, I'll just go v- you know, sample grapes for you.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. You, you give them the check or the double plus. We-

Doug Shafer

Okay. (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

That's, isn't that great? I, I just love it. We, we have, own the LLC now, you know. We just applied for it and we got it, so...

Doug Shafer

Good.

Tom Rinaldi

It's, it, the rest is history.

Doug Shafer

Good, good, good. Well, go trademark it, 'cause I might take it. I like it. No, I'm not gonna do that.

Tom Rinaldi

It's done.

Doug Shafer

Okay, good.

Tom Rinaldi

It's done.

Doug Shafer

Good.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah.

Doug Shafer

All right, Mr. Rinaldi. Thank you so much for taking the time today. And-

Tom Rinaldi

My pleasure, indeed. Yeah.

Doug Shafer

And, uh, great, great to hear your stories and, uh, I miss seeing you, I miss seeing you on the road, so, uh, I'll see you out there on the, on the cycling days one of these days soon. Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

Yeah. And one of these days we gotta refresh that, that story about your, uh, d- idea to make a Port out of Hillside Select. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

(laughs) Yeah, that was, yeah. That didn't go over really well with my Dad, but that's a...

Tom Rinaldi

No kidding. (laughs)

Doug Shafer

Okay. (laughs)

Tom Rinaldi

I can still hear the screaming.

Doug Shafer

Oh god. Yeah.

Tom Rinaldi

All right.

Doug Shafer

His quote was, "You took 200 gallons of my Cabernet and did this to it?" It was not good.

Tom Rinaldi

(laughs)

Doug Shafer

It was not good. Um...

Tom Rinaldi

What's your marketing plan? Oh, boy.

Doug Shafer

Oh, yeah. A couple of rookies, Elias and me. All right, Tommy. Take care. Great talking to you and, and be safe out there. We'll see you.

Tom Rinaldi

Fare thee well.

Doug Shafer

All right.

Tom Rinaldi

Bye bye.

Doug Shafer

Bye.