The TastePodcast
Beth and Lindy Novak
Beth and Lindy Novak have lots of great memories of growing up in Napa Valley including hanging out with the Shafer kids. But things got tough when their father died unexpectedly and their mother, Mary Novak, had to figure out her next steps. Fortunately Mary and her daughters created Spottswoode Estate, turning it into one of the top wineries in Napa Valley. Enjoy! For more visit: spottswoode.com
65 min listen67 min read

Interview transcript
Doug Shafer
Welcome back everybody. Um, we have a special day today, this is the first time on The Taste that I've had not one guest, but two, and these two folks have been very patient, and we've been trying to get together, and the reason I haven't told you why it took so long is we had to get a ... another microphone (laughs) so that's part of the delay.
Um, special treat today, two siblings here, long time personal friends, professional friends, our families started their relationship many, many years ago, I think over 40 years.
Beth Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Parents. Um Beth and Lindy Novak in charge of a truly great, historic, top quality family vineyard and wine estate in St. Helena, Spottswoode. Welcome guys.
Lindy Novak
Thank you very much.
Beth Novak
Thanks for having us here.
Doug Shafer
Good to be here. Get you two in the same room.
Beth Novak
It happens.
Doug Shafer
Sisters, sisters.
Beth Novak
(Laughs) occasionally, yes.
Doug Shafer
So ... Spottswoode, there's so many stories. There's the 1800s, there's before that, your folk's story, your stories, it's gonna be kinda crazy today, we're jumping all over, but you guys run with it as far as who talks when, you know, it's a sister sibling thing, I'll let you two figure that one out. I'll be, I'm not gonna get involved in that.
Lindy Novak
Get involved in that? So can we break our sister song?
Beth Novak
We could.
Doug Shafer
But um ... we could.
Beth Novak
We could indeed, yes. Yeah, we could.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs) but let's start in the beginning. Spottswoode, when did they start growing grapes at the Spottswoode estate?
Beth Novak
So, it was established as Spottswoode Estate in 1882 by a German immigrant who was a hotel manager down in Monterey. And so when he came to St. Helena and established this property that is now called Spottswoode, um, he designed it, uh, architecturally, it, to mimic what was down there, obviously on a much smaller scale.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
The Hotel Del Monte in Monterey is no longer there, it burned twice, and they ultimately moved out to Pebble Beach, that's why it's called the Del Monte Lodge in Pebble Beach, but-
Doug Shafer
Oh that's why.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
So ... because it was the Del Monte forest, but there was this beautiful old- old hotel built around the same time as the Hotel Del Coronado.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
It's one of those old Victorian hotels that people would spend a lot of time at when people used to have a lot of time to spend places, unlike today.
Lindy Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
That's ... that's true, well that's amaze, the, now, now I know the answer because Spottswoode is an amazingly gorgeous place, and so unique in St. Helena. .
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
So it's like, where'd that architecture come from? Okay.
Beth Novak
So that's- so he brought it up, he established the property in 1882, he did plant vines, we don't know what he planted, and he named the estate Esmeralda, which is "the emerald" in Spanish. And then he and his wife Catherine owned it until she passed away a couple years later, he sold it in 1906 to a family who named it Stonehearst 00:03:54 and then in '08 it was sold to a family who named it Lyndonhearst. And then ultimately, in 1910, a woman named Mrs. Spotts purchased it, and she named it Spottswoode in her late husband's memory.
Doug Shafer
Mrs. Spotts.
Beth Novak
Mrs, Spotts.
Lindy Novak
Albert and Susan.
Doug Shafer
That was what? What year was that? 19-
Beth Novak
Uh, 1910 is when she bought it.
Doug Shafer
1910. Mrs. Spotts.
Beth Novak
Exactly, Mrs. Spots. And she named it Spottswoode, who knows, go figure.
Lindy Novak
Yep, I think she thought Spotts was too plain and boring.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Yeah .
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
But there was an original governor of Virginia, or one of the early governors of Virginia was a Spottswoode, maybe with no E.
Lindy Novak
So there were some-
Doug Shafer
Okay, so-
Beth Novak
She pulled it from ...
Doug Shafer
That's 1910, was she growing grapes?
Beth Novak
So we have to assume, we've never been able to figure out what George Schonewald planted. We have to assume that there were vines there.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
When, when she got there, or when he, yeah, when Mrs. Spotts got there. Um, but then, what was Prohibition, 1919 to 1933.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
So by the time bought the property, my- our parents.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Beth Novak
Our mom and dad bought the property in 1972, there were post-Prohibition vines in the ground.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
So somewhere along the way, the vine- the original vines obviously went by the wayside because when we got there, there was a Petite Sirah, Napa Gamay, French Columbard, and Green Hungarian, you know, just those post-
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Post-prohibition vines that were in the ground, and so whatever had been planted originally, we don't know.
Doug Shafer
Okay. Fair enough. Alright, your folks. How'd they- how'd those two get together?
Beth Novak
Uh, go ahead.
Lindy Novak
Oh.
Doug Shafer
Lind, uh, take it away Lindy!
Lindy Novak
(Laughs) yeah, whoa.
Doug Shafer
This is fun, I might kind of have to play, oh, say, Lindy's right now.
Lindy Novak
Okay. Okay. So you tell me if I've, if I get most of the details right. Mom and Dad, uh, were at Stanford together. Dad's first year in college was in Notre, at Notre Dame.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
Back in Indiana, and that's where he met Ray Duncan, and Ray Duncan actually ended up out here in part because Dad was looking at vineyards and-
Doug Shafer
Ray Duncan who is-
Lindy Novak
Started Silver Oak.
Doug Shafer
... no longer with us, but he starts Silver Oak with Justin Meyers.
Lindy Novak
That's right. Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And the Duncan family owns it now.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Wow, I didn't know that one. See? I told you there'd be things I didn't know.
Beth Novak
Yeah. But wait a minute, they didn't meet there, I do have to correct you.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
So, so my dad's, our dad's parents knew Ray Duncan's parents for some reason.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
And so when Dad went back, because he was born and raised in North San Diego County. So when he went back to Notre Dame in his first year, Ray was a couple years older than, than our dad was.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
And so they, they sort of said, "Hey," they said to Ray, "Take care of this, you know, this man coming out from uh, this young man coming out from California."
Lindy Novak
Befriend him.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
Befriend him, take care of him, under your wing. Which he did, but, but Dad only lasted a year because the weather was so awful.
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Beth Novak
That he didn't like it, and then he came back to Stanford and Lindy can, or came to Stanford, and Lindy can take it from there.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, so it's, it's uh ...
Doug Shafer
But he grew up in California.
Lindy Novak
Southern California.
Beth Novak
Southern California. Yep.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
San Diego County, yep. Uh, so I believe ... were they going up to Mammoth Lakes for a ski weekend? And somebody connected them ... because m- our mom wanted to go to church, she was a practicing Catholic.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
Uh, and um, I believe somebody connected her with Dad, so that she could, he, he could give her a ride to church?
Beth Novak
Yeah, and I think it was Tahoe. But yes.
Lindy Novak
Okay. Okay, so that is how they got together and uh, I think, Dad was a fairly wild person in college, and I think Mom probably scratched her head, but he was fun.
Beth Novak
Right.
Lindy Novak
And so they uh, got together and uh, and stayed together and got married and ended up down in Los Angeles, which is where I was born.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
And then we moved back down to uh, uh, a town called Rancho Santa Fe in San Diego County.
Doug Shafer
In San Diego County, right?
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Okay, and, and he was a doctor.
Lindy Novak
He was.
Beth Novak
Correct.
Doug Shafer
So they're married, San Diego, he's a doctor. They have not one, not two, not three, four, five kids.
Beth Novak
Five children.
Doug Shafer
Got it.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
And all of a sudden they come up to the Napa Valley, how ... how'd that happen?
Lindy Novak
That was the, the Sandbergs, uh, our friends the uh, Sandberg family, uh, knew the Chappellets and they were living in Los Angeles in Pasadena, and uh, didn't they, they decided to move up here, to uh-
Beth Novak
Yeah, Charlie and Joan Sandberg had also both gone to Stanford, and that's how Mom and Dad knew them, our mom and dad knew them.
Doug Shafer
Got it.
Lindy Novak
Yep.
Beth Novak
So then they came up one time and visited.
Doug Shafer
And visited.
Beth Novak
We visited them over Thanksgiving, it was pouring rain, but we came up and visited and ... White Hall Lane, now where, um, Dana Estates is, that's where they lived.
Doug Shafer
Okay. Yeah, yeah, I remember that.
Beth Novak
Right. So we came up and, and visited, and uh, it seemed to me shortly thereafter, uh, Dad was seriously looking at properties up here.
Doug Shafer
Okay so-
Beth Novak
With the intention of uh ...
Lindy Novak
So he's, yeah, he's 39.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
And it's probably something like your dad, you know, it's probably not that different. Dad's 39, he's a doctor down in San Diego, North San Diego County with uh, five children and a full time practice, and things are fine but he's 39 years old and he's, kinda bored and thinking, "I don't want to raise all my five children down here in this sort of environment."
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
Which felt was changing toward a more wealthy kind of uh, enclave then, and he had been born and raised in this place. And they just started looking around and for some reason this notion of agriculture, probably again, no different than your dad, wanting to raise your children in this more pastoral, rural, agrarian world.
Beth Novak
Agrarian.
Doug Shafer
Right. Well Dad was 48.
Lindy Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
And um ... he was looking for another gig.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And um ... he ... he'd right- he'd actually done some research and read that this, this pending wine boom was gonna take off.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
He was not a wine lover.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
He, he did it from an investment standpoint.
Lindy Novak
Really?
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Oh, didn't you see?
Lindy Novak
Oh, okay, I did, I didn't know that he from the investment, yeah.
Doug Shafer
No, he was ... he worked for this publishing company in Chicago for 22 years.
Beth Novak
Yes. Yes.
Doug Shafer
His job was long range planning. So today his job would be ... he read the tea leaves, what's coming.
Lindy Novak
Got it.
Doug Shafer
Like today, for this publishing company, it's like, okay, Snapchat, we gotta get involved in this.
Beth Novak
Correct.
Doug Shafer
So he kept coming across different trends.
Beth Novak
Aha.
Doug Shafer
And one was technology.
Lindy Novak
Okay. Uh-huh.
Doug Shafer
Reel to reel tape machines, which morphed into cellphones and technology.
Lindy Novak
Right, yeah, right.
Doug Shafer
And one was the pending wine boom. So he simultaneously, he went to his bosses-
Lindy Novak
Got it.
Doug Shafer
And said, "We gotta go tech." And they said, "No, we'll stick with the workbook and the reader." This is 1970-ish.
Beth Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
Oh, okay.
Doug Shafer
Meanwhile, this wine boom, it's like, "I gotta check this out from a personal standpoint, personal investment."
Lindy Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
He came out here, and you're gonna get a kick out of this, because when did your folks buy Spottswoode?
Beth Novak
1972, and luckily your dad didn't.
Lindy Novak
1972.
Doug Shafer
Luckily he didn't, you know that story.
Beth Novak
Because he looked at it.
Doug Shafer
So he looked at it.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
And um, so he came out and looked at a bunch of properties, looked at Spottswoode, which my kids to this day, it's like, "We could've been living in that house, what's going on?"
Beth Novak
(Laughs)
Lindy Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
"That beautiful home." And he ended, but he wanted to do something with hillside grapes so we ended up down here in Stags Leap.
Beth Novak
Right.
Lindy Novak
I thought it was because he didn't want another old house, I thought you guys had kind of an old house in the, the Chicago area?
Doug Shafer
Oh no, it was a great house.
Lindy Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
Great old beautiful home.
Beth Novak
He said he didn't want to fix up some, another, another old house.
Lindy Novak
Another old.
Doug Shafer
Really? That's what he, I, that's what he had said?
Beth Novak
Yeah, I was having dinner with him at uh, yeah, Rodney Deans you know, maybe six months ago, and he said yeah, he just looked at it and said, "I just don't, I don't want to deal with another old house."
Doug Shafer
What?
Lindy Novak
Too much work.
Beth Novak
Isn't that funny?
Doug Shafer
I've never heard that one.
Beth Novak
Yeah. You'll have to ask.
Doug Shafer
Here I thought it was the hillside vineyard thing.
Beth Novak
It could've been.
Doug Shafer
Oh boy what do you, what do you know?
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
That's funny.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Alright-
Lindy Novak
But I, I don't ... our dad didn't have a, uh, sort of a premeditated about where wine was gonna go, it was more spontaneous. It was just a lifestyle.
Doug Shafer
Spontaneous, so it was most, mostly lifestyle.
Lindy Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
Got it.
Lindy Novak
It was lifestyle, he had no thought.
Doug Shafer
So his plan was to come up here and have a practice, medical practice.
Beth Novak
No.
Lindy Novak
No.
Doug Shafer
No, oh!
Lindy Novak
He quit medicine.
Beth Novak
Uh-huh.
Doug Shafer
He quit medicine. Didn't know that.
Lindy Novak
He quit medicine, sold his practice.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
So he was a general practitioner and he sold it, and we moved up.
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Beth Novak
They sold everything, they sold the house, the practice, everything. My mom said they wanted to make sure to make the, a clean cut so that there was no sort of thought that, "Well there's a fallback position if it doesn't work."
Doug Shafer
Right, you could go back.
Lindy Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Lindy Novak
And we had just-
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
... built a really nice house down there, I mean it was a ... it was quite a ... I enjoyed the lifestyle down there, being close to the beach and there was a lot of horseback riding, and I mean it was a great, it, it, you know, Rancho Santa Fe was relatively rural also.
Beth Novak
That's true.
Lindy Novak
Not in the same way as Napa.
Beth Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
But, yeah, it was. It was very nice.
Doug Shafer
So you moved up here, how, how old are you guys when you moved up?
Lindy Novak
I'm the oldest of the five of us and I was 15.
Doug Shafer
15.
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, I was ... well, I, I was sort of mortified, it was leaving the beach and leaving-
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
... all of our friends, and I think the rest of the kids had a, uh, I mean Beth can speak for herself but it seemed like there, the kids were like, "Oh this could be kind of a fun adventure." But I was a little bummed.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
When we first looked in the gate at Spottswoode, it looked like the Munsters lived there, I thought, you know.
Doug Shafer
I'm with you. I can see that.
Lindy Novak
Cobwebby and dark and uh, so ...
Doug Shafer
You got the wrought iron gate.
Lindy Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
The stone columns.
Lindy Novak
Right, yeah. So I was, I was a little surprised myself.
Doug Shafer
How about you, Beth?
Beth Novak
I was along for the ride, I didn't even think about it. Like, I thought it was great. I loved coming up here.
Doug Shafer
Great.
Beth Novak
I'm right in the middle of the five, so I have two older sisters and two younger brothers, and at the time I was probably hanging a lot more with my brothers than I was with my sisters and ... yeah, I was 11, so I hadn't hit the teenage years yet. I was ... it didn't impact me.
Doug Shafer
Having a gas.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
I, I'm, I'm, yeah, I liked it.
Lindy Novak
Well I was, I had entered the teenage years, those are a little tricky.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Lindy Novak
Just inherently, aren't they?
Doug Shafer
Yeah, yeah.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
They're tough.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Okay, so you landed here, so and ... it was '72, we moved out in '73, I was in ... finishing high school. So I don't remember meeting you guys when I was in high school here, I remember meeting you guys when I was, in my college years. We'd come back and ...
Lindy Novak
Right. I-
Doug Shafer
Christmas time, and Christmas at your mom's house, she'd always have a Christmas party.
Lindy Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
I remember those, and then summertimes, I guess.
Lindy Novak
So when did we come up here and play pool? I thought that was when we were in ... when I was in high school and you were in high school.
Doug Shafer
It might've been.
Lindy Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
We were, we would try to, you know, because, you know, it was ... your parents, my parents, we were both new to the Valley.
Lindy Novak
That's right. Yeah. And I think they were trying to help us, you know, forge family friendships and kinda find a network that, of people that we liked up here.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Oh we, we had this great bumper pool table and ...
Lindy Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
I don't know, I mean it was like, what's bumper pool?
Lindy Novak
I had forgotten, I-
Doug Shafer
I remember everybody was like, "What a strange game." It's really-
Lindy Novak
Yeah, bumper pool's cool, I barely remembered it, it was fun.
Doug Shafer
It's a cool game.
Lindy Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
It's still up there.
Beth Novak
Really.
Doug Shafer
I should get it, I should grab that table.
Lindy Novak
Oh my god, you should.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
You should.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Fun game.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Lindy Novak
Yeah I- yeah.
Doug Shafer
So we used to do that, and then um ...
Lindy Novak
Well we didn't see each other, I think you're a teeny bit uh, ahead of me in age but I started out at St. Helena High for all of three days, and I was very shy and uh, wasn't happy about it at all, so I, I, my parents said, well we'll, you can try Justin-Siena in Napa.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
And so uh, down there I went and was introduced to a couple of nuns who were running the school and uh, I didn't like that either, but Mom and Dad said, "Well, that, you know, this, these are your options."
Doug Shafer
Those are your two choices.
Beth Novak
Right.
Lindy Novak
So I ended up in, at Justin and commuted down there with, uh, Heidi Peterson Barrett.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
Was one of the people in my little carpool group.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
So ... so we didn't overlap, and then Beth can- she-
Doug Shafer
Now what about my little brother, Brad? Did you guys know, you probably knew Brad.
Beth Novak
I think Kelly, our ... the sister between us had a crush on Brad.
Doug Shafer
Oh the ... I think they kinda went, they had a thing.
Beth Novak
I think there was, there was a little crush there, I think.
Doug Shafer
It was a thing, okay.
Beth Novak
Yeah. Brad played tennis, yeah.
Doug Shafer
Okay. Well I'm glad the-
Beth Novak
I think he had good legs. Just a memory.
Doug Shafer
Oh man, I'm glad the Novaks and Shafers hooked up one way or the other (laughs).
Lindy Novak
(Laughs) Yeah there, I think there might have been a few crushes, and even with, maybe with the Chappellet family too. You know, the, the, we spent time with them and I might have had a crush on Cyril.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
You might wanna cut that out of the interview (laughs).
Doug Shafer
No, no, Cyril will-
Beth Novak
No, Cyril, Cyril will love that. Don't do that.
Lindy Novak
Right (laughs).
Doug Shafer
Cyril and I, you know, we played basketball together in high school.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
That was fun.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And then there were the uh, the famous Mondavi concerts in the summer.
Lindy Novak
There were.
Doug Shafer
Which, which were fun.
Beth Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative), yeah.
Doug Shafer
We all used to get together and picnic.
Beth Novak
Yes. Yes.
Doug Shafer
In the hot sun for three hours before the music came on.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Yes, and fireworks and uh, uh yeah there was certain uh, certain people had maybe a little too much fun there (laughs).
Doug Shafer
Oh, we all did.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, it was great though.
Doug Shafer
Including you.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And me.
Lindy Novak
That's right. Yeah.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
So good times, so um ... And then, you guys had a, huh, you had a rough one. You know, your dad.
Lindy Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
That was tough.
Beth Novak
Yep.
Doug Shafer
So that was ... he was, how old was he?
Beth Novak
44.
Doug Shafer
44.
Beth Novak
So yeah, five years after we ... not quite five years after we moved here, but yeah, he died of a heart attack unexpectedly.
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Beth Novak
So he was uh ... he had something called cardiac arrhythmia which we didn't really know, I mean doctors are ... there's a lot of interesting things about doctors and hopefully I don't offend anybody who's a doctor who might be listening, but doctors, A: don't necessarily plan, I mean, we were talking about how your dad really mapped out his move here. Our dad just was like, I think doctors just think, "If I want to make it happen I'll just make it happen somehow and I'll figure out a way." Right? So move up here, buy this ... you know, sold everything down south.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
Buy this property, five children, replanting vineyard, fixing up the house. Buying things with Ray Duncan, you know, just this and that, racing in the Baja 1000 and 500 races, I mean, just doing it all. So it's like, well you're spending a lot of money, but you're earning zero.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
So ... so Dad, we had, my mom's side of the family had a financial advisor who said, "You know Jack, you've gotta go back to work." And our dad promptly fired him and then went back to work as a doctor, so-
Lindy Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
I didn't know that, okay.
Beth Novak
He was an ER doctor for just a few years up here.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
In '76, maybe late '75, for sure '76, and then part of '77.
Lindy Novak
At St. Helena Hospital.
Beth Novak
At St. Helena hospital, thank you. And then um, because I was home, I was home doing homework upstairs, but he was out playing tennis with Tony Holzhauer.
Doug Shafer
Right, right.
Beth Novak
Also a man that you know, a family friend. And he got um, an emergency phone call, or an emergency beep. You know, and in those days there were no cellphones, he went in and-
Doug Shafer
Just beepers, right.
Beth Novak
... took the fa- uh, you know, called the hospital from the kitchen and came back out to tell Tony that he had to take off and go to this emergency. And at that point in time, he sort of grabbed his chest apparently and said, "Oh no, not me," and fell.
Doug Shafer
Oh man.
Beth Novak
And uh ... it was a massive heart attack that he had, and Tony did everything he could to try to resuscitate him and couldn't.
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Beth Novak
So ambulance came, uh, took him up to the ER and uh, that was in October, uh, of '77. Uh, took him up to the, to the hospital, and then he ultimately ... he had been without oxygen for nine minutes.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
So uh, he was brain dead.
Doug Shafer
He was gone.
Beth Novak
Uh, and so he did live for a while, he was on life support and things, and then thankfully our mom made the choice to take him off, which was the only-
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Yeah, moral choice to make.
Lindy Novak
Alternative.
Beth Novak
And uh, and then he died on November 14th, so about three weeks after his heart attack.
Doug Shafer
Oh you guys, that's tough. That's-
Beth Novak
So it was hard.
Doug Shafer
You're in high school?
Beth Novak
Yes. I was in high school.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, and I had gone off to college, I was at UCLA, but-
Doug Shafer
You, you went off to college.
Lindy Novak
Uh, and I had come home, um, uh, maybe three weeks before he passed away and he had all this apparatus all over his chest, so.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Oh you remember that too.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, so I asked to, I asked uh, "What are you doing? Are you alright?" And he said, "Well I've got a condition, could be serious." And I thought, "That's a little odd," and then I went back to school.
Doug Shafer
Huh.
Lindy Novak
And was at my aunt's house in uh, West LA, and got the phone call that he had passed away.
Doug Shafer
I have a, I have a faint memory of him.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, yeah.
Doug Shafer
And what I remember, what you guys need to know, my faint is- because it's faint, but I was thinking about you guys last night.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And reading, you know, reading up on history. And I remember a really good looking, vivacious, ath- great athlete.
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Doug Shafer
Like, larger than life type of person.
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative). Yeah, he was, I would agree.
Doug Shafer
But he was just, I only met him a handful of times.
Lindy Novak
Yep.
Doug Shafer
But the guy was like a presence, he was like ...
Beth Novak
Yeah. He had charisma, he did.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
He did have the-
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
He definitely did.
Doug Shafer
A ton of charisma.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, but he reminded a little bit of Ernest Hemingway, uh, just-
Doug Shafer
Hm.
Lindy Novak
You know, very masculine guy and uh, not afraid to take risks, I mean, maybe, maybe to the point where sometimes that drove Mom a little crazy and ... as Beth said, off doing these, you know, Baja races and he bought a car dealership in Montana.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs).
Lindy Novak
Just did these things that were, you know-
Beth Novak
They were not, not very, not very smart yeah, it's always like, thank god he was uh, not a business man.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Okay, so ...
Beth Novak
He wouldn't have ever made the move, yeah.
Doug Shafer
But speaking of your mom. So here she is, husband's gone, five kids.
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
Living on this big, beautiful estate. Vineyards. What'd she do?
Beth Novak
So I mean, she ... thankf- she took stock, I mean, she had, and, and, I mean, she was the same age, um ... you know, she had already fallen in love with the area, she had made good friends.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
And what she recognized, and I only know this because I was still there, is that she had a livelihood, you know? She had, they had replanted the vineyard after we moved there so we'd removed the grapes that I mentioned earlier and we had planted ... It's a 45 acre estate.
Doug Shafer
Got it.
Beth Novak
Total, of which 40 is planted, and we had about nine acres each of sauvignon blanc and zinfandel, and about 20 acres of cabernet.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
Which ultimately you guys started to buy some of.
Doug Shafer
Right, right.
Beth Novak
And so she realized that she had a livelihood and she wanted to stay up in ... up in St. Helena and keep us there, I mean the three of us that were still there.
Lindy Novak
But she did toy with the idea of ... it was my understanding she toyed with the idea of moving back to Los Angeles.
Doug Shafer
Did she. Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Where her family was from initially because it was-
Doug Shafer
Well it's a lot.
Lindy Novak
The whole thing was such a shock.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Yeah, it was a lot and there was a lot of debt. I mean, Dad had left, you know, debt, and there was a property that we had bought down the street.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
And my mom, I mean, our mom really had to consolidate stuff.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
You know, and luckily our uncle Carl helped her out and bought this one property that, from her and sort of ... did-
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
You know, did some things to help her out because she really had to get things organized in order to be able to stay here. So she decided to, and then I think that the one ... I, the one thing that I really remember living there, that I think probably cemented her resolve, which I think was already there, but probably actually just made it really happen is that I remember a realtor walked up the front stairs and came to the front door and knocked on the door, and said, "Oh, hi Mrs. Novak. You know, we understand you may be selling." And I mean, I never ... you knew my mom.
Doug Shafer
Oh, (laughs).
Beth Novak
She didn't like, lose her temper much, but she was strong, but she was-
Doug Shafer
I bet that she took him down.
Beth Novak
She was furious.
Doug Shafer
Oh.
Beth Novak
She said, "Get off my porch. Just because I am left a widow here, I am, that does not mean I'm selling, and if it had been the other way around and, and my husband, you know, I had died and my husband was here you wouldn't be up here asking him if he was gonna sell."
Doug Shafer
Oh I can see her, I can see her lighting him up.
Beth Novak
"So just get off my porch." She was, she was furious. So I think, and I think probably that that um, experience really helped her like, just, "I am not, I'm not going anywhere. I'm, I'm going to make this work. I don't want people thinking that I can't."
Doug Shafer
Lock it in.
Beth Novak
Yep.
Lindy Novak
We had just started selling fruit to, uh, Charlie Wagner, hadn't we? Mom and Dad together?
Beth Novak
They may have sold some to Caymus to Robert Mondavi had bought some of the Napa Gamay.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
Yep.
Beth Novak
To, you know, the old days of um ... God, of St. Clement? With, yep, yep.
Doug Shafer
Oh yeah, St. Clement.
Beth Novak
And uh, and then, and then Frog's Leap even, I think, I think we sort of got John, and at that time Julian into the zinfandel business because they were buying sauvignon blanc and cab from us, and we were like, "We need you to buy our zinfandel too."
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
So they did. We may have had something to do with that, I'd have to ask John.
Doug Shafer
I think you probably did.
Beth Novak
We may have.
Doug Shafer
And we were buying cab, I was trying to-
Lindy Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
I was too lazy I can't find my old files, but I'm not sure what years, but it had to be in the mid to late 80s, I think it was uh, four or five years ... you were-
Beth Novak
I, I think it might have been late 70s.
Doug Shafer
Could've been.
Beth Novak
I think, I think you started buying in '78 or '79?
Doug Shafer
Well '78 we didn't purchase anything.
Beth Novak
Okay
Doug Shafer
Maybe '79. Yeah.
Beth Novak
'79 or '80? Because I think-
Doug Shafer
It the, it was a string of years.
Beth Novak
There were, and you and your ... and, if you were here then, when did you start here?
Doug Shafer
I started in '83.
Beth Novak
Okay, because, so you -
Doug Shafer
But our pre- we had another guy, Nico Shalck was here for a couple years, do you remember meeting him?
Beth Novak
I don't, but I wasn't at Spottswoode then.
Doug Shafer
Got it.
Beth Novak
I was still in college.
Doug Shafer
You were still in college.
Beth Novak
So ... I think though, I mean, and the story I always tell when I talk about how we got started is both you, your family and um, the Duckhorn family-
Doug Shafer
Duckhorns would purchase, right.
Lindy Novak
... were buying our fruit and really, really encouraged Mom to, to make wine, and ... because you felt like the fruit had something special and you had recognized their shared dream, you know, of, of doing that, so that's my, that's my recollection. I think you buying.
Doug Shafer
I think Dad, yeah, I think Dad and Dan probably talked to your mom at that point.
Lindy Novak
I think so too.
Beth Novak
Doug was it, was there any vineyard here when you moved here? Or did you plant it all?
Doug Shafer
Yeah, it was um ...
Beth Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
30 acres of 60 year old vines.
Beth Novak
Wow.
Doug Shafer
Same type of thing, chenin blanc,
Beth Novak
Yep.
Doug Shafer
Carignane.
Beth Novak
Oh, okay.
Doug Shafer
Petite Sirah, zinfandel.
Beth Novak
Who had planted it?
Doug Shafer
Uh, Batista Scanzi in 1922.
Lindy Novak
Wow. Okay. Yeah.
Doug Shafer
There you go.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
That's cool.
Doug Shafer
So same deal.
Lindy Novak
Yep.
Beth Novak
So 22 acres planted, but how many do you have now?
Doug Shafer
It was uh ... was it 22 and then it was third- no it was um, 30-ish, about 30, 32.
Beth Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
And now we've got 55.
Beth Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
That's, that's all we've got.
Beth Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
On this, on this ranch.
Beth Novak
Such a great property here.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Yeah, it is a beautiful place.
Beth Novak
It is pretty over here.
Doug Shafer
Thanks. Well, I do remember, so ... we might have been purchasing grapes from you guys before I came on board, but then I came on board and so my deal at the time was ... whenever we're picking grapes somewhere, whether it's our property or some, a grower's.
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
I need to get there that morning to make sure they're using the right size gondola, to make sure they're picking the right rows.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
I think, this came from having mistakes happen.
Lindy Novak
(Laughs).
Beth Novak
Absolutely. You have to do that. No, that totally makes sense.
Doug Shafer
And so- but this is before cellphones, you know.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And Elias is trying ... you know, so I'm in my car running all over the Valley.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
Because he ... and it was like, vital, you had to get to everything and every day at, at the start. So I'd always, on picking Spottswoode days, I'd always pull in, I'd just pull right in the driveway right at the main house. I was early and the kitchen light was on and your mom's in there.
And she saw me pull up, she goes, "Come on, Doug, come on in." So I'd, I'd, I would, I got ... you've heard this story.
Beth Novak
Yeah, I love this story, it's a great one, I'd like to hear it again.
Doug Shafer
I'll tell it again, I would, she'd invite me into her kitchen, you know, I'd have a cup of coffee with her.
Beth Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Doug Shafer
And we would just be chatting.
Beth Novak
Yep.
Doug Shafer
You know, "How's it looking?" "Oh, the weather looks great, the fruit looks good. It's a little light, it's a little heavy, I think we're nailing it ... bla da da da." I mean, just, you know, how are the kids? How's, you know.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
How's the baby? Just ...
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
Just the most normal kind of ...
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And she was puttering around the kitchen, getting things going.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And then, I'd be there for like, ten, fifteen minutes, and it's like, you know, the guys are starting to pick, "Gotta run. See you, thanks for the coffee."
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Yep.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
It happened time after time.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Just like, that's, that's your mom to me.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Yeah, she was a great one.
Doug Shafer
I mean it was ... I'll never forget it.
Lindy Novak
And coffee was very important to her (laughs).
Beth Novak
Oh yes.
Doug Shafer
Oh yeah, all of us.
Beth Novak
Yeah (laughs).
Lindy Novak
Exactly.
Beth Novak
Yeah, what would we do without that?
Doug Shafer
So she's growing grapes, selling grapes. Um, making a go at it. So how did ... whose idea was it to start making wine? Well Dad and Duckhorn and a few other people convinced her.
Beth Novak
Kind of, kinda encouraged her and then, and then ultimately-
Doug Shafer
And she went for it.
Beth Novak
And, and Tony Soter was uh, I guess in the inter- interviewing and I don't know how many people she spoke with but uh, Tony was um ... interested in uh, in it, he had been out, he was up at Chappellet, he was living there, had been making wines there.
Doug Shafer
Right, right.
Beth Novak
Uh, wanted to start his own brand, which was called Etude and uh ... which he also started in 1982, and that was our first vintage, a cabernet, and I guess Mom, Mom, in interviewing him liked him and, and brought him on board. And we actually crushed our first harvest at Hafner and ...
Doug Shafer
At Hafner Vineyards up in Healdsburg.
Beth Novak
Yes, yeah.
Doug Shafer
That's, because I was gonna ask you where you crushed.
Beth Novak
Yep. First year at Hafner.
Doug Shafer
That's a long drive, that's a 45 minute drive.
Beth Novak
That is a long drive. And Tony did his pinot up there too, so you probably know, is it Park, right?
Doug Shafer
It's Park Hafner.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Who I met ... (laughs) you're gonna love this one.
Beth Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
I've, you know, to all our folks out there, if it's too much, you know, history.
Beth Novak
Too much information, right.
Doug Shafer
Too much information it's, it's the way it's gonna be.
Beth Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
Park Hafner, Hafner Vineyards up in Healdsburg.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
I'm at UC Davis, freshman year, Chem 1A, my first chemistry class, I'm in the lab, and I'm sitting across this table from this guy, and you know, we're, you know, freshmen in college. "Hi, I'm Doug Shafer." "Hi, I'm Park Hafner." You know, "Where you from?" "Well I'm Healdsburg, my dad's got a vineyard." "Well Napa, my dad's got a vineyard." That's when I first met Park.
Lindy Novak
Oh that's great.
Doug Shafer
I know.
Lindy Novak
That's great.
Beth Novak
Does Hafner still exist?
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Oh yeah.
Beth Novak
Okay.
Lindy Novak
I just ran into him up in ...
Doug Shafer
They do a great job.
Beth Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
So um, yeah, Park's a pal.
Beth Novak
That's nice to hear.
Doug Shafer
That's funny.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Yep.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, so Tony's, Tony uh ...
Doug Shafer
Tony started in '82.
Lindy Novak
Yep, and so uh ... and then uh, Mom started chatting with Beth about uh, coming up and uh, helping her. And ...
Beth Novak
Yeah, that wasn't, that wasn't until 1987, so ...
Doug Shafer
Yeah but ... well no this was ...
Lindy Novak
Oh that was later.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
I'm sorry.
Doug Shafer
Well let's roll this, well where were, Lindy where were you? Because you were in ... you went to college where?
Lindy Novak
I did, I went to UCLA for two years.
Doug Shafer
Got it.
Lindy Novak
And I, uh, the quarter that uh, Dad passed away, I had set in motion plan to transfer to Cal.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
Uh, with another friend of mine from Santa Barbara, so I ended up at Cal.
Doug Shafer
Got it.
Lindy Novak
And I was a geography major, I, I thought maybe I would go into some kind of environmental planning.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
I wasn't really sure. And then, uh, when I graduated, um, uh, I had a, uh, sort of a subsidiary interest in fashion and a close friend of ours knew Phil Schlein who ended up making wine up here, and he was then-
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
... the president of Macy's California, and she set up an interview for me at his house in Pacific Heights with he and his wife.
Doug Shafer
Oh neat.
Lindy Novak
And uh, he was a really dynamic guy, this was in the years when uh, retail, uh, was um, uh, the stores were beautiful and Macy's was very high end and so I-
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
I-
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
It was way before online things.
Lindy Novak
That's right. That's right. So I ended up, uh, working for Macy's in the City and uh, was with them for about four years and then uh, decided that I wasn't really fond of the retail work schedule.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
And uh, wasn't really a, a great fit for uh, corporate life. So I uh, left and um, hooked up with a really nice guy, he became my boss and I sold clothing, so we worked in the Apparel Mart at 821 Market Street in San Francisco.
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Lindy Novak
And uh, I was-
Beth Novak
You sold swimwear.
Lindy Novak
I did, I ended up selling swimwear and uh, that was fun. We had a lot of uh-
Beth Novak
Yes.
Lindy Novak
... fashion shows trying on swimwear.
Beth Novak
Fashion shows.
Lindy Novak
And ... uh-huh.
Doug Shafer
The sisters getting together, trying on suits.
Lindy Novak
(Laughs) yep, and trying on the swimwear, rather. Or-
Doug Shafer
There you go.
Lindy Novak
It was fun.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. So I covered Northern California, Oregon and Washington.
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
So.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
And you got to go to Lolo's Large and Lovely in Lake County.
Lindy Novak
Oh god, you're gonna tell that story?
Beth Novak
To sell bathing suits. That's a pretty good one.
Lindy Novak
I sold to a variety of establishments, and one of them was uh, was a trailer in uh, in Lake County.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs) Thanks man, I love it.
Lindy Novak
And uh-
Doug Shafer
A trailer in Lake County?
Lindy Novak
A trailer in Lake County.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
And I do believe she ended up buying some, some swimwear.
Beth Novak
Lolo's Large and Lovely, wasn't it?
Lindy Novak
(Laughs) I think it was. Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Well ... well look at, because we'll, we'll talk a little later about what you do now for Spottswoode.
Lindy Novak
Okay. Yeah, yeah.
Doug Shafer
But what a great education for selling wine.
Lindy Novak
Exactly.
Beth Novak
That's right.
Doug Shafer
I mean, look, we all, the three of us.
Beth Novak
That's right.
Doug Shafer
We've all sold wine, and you name it, we've sold it there.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. We, we have.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
We have (laughs).
Doug Shafer
Well that's like me, my training was teaching junior high school.
Beth Novak
Yeah, right.
Doug Shafer
That's why I can handle any, any type of ...
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
... crowd, any time.
Beth Novak
Right.
Lindy Novak
And I, I, I've listened to, I think all of your podcasts as I've said, and sort of, sort of gleaned some additional, you know, knowledge about how you c-came back to the winery, but why- did you leave teaching because your dad wanted your help? Why did you leave teaching? Was it a burnout? Or ...
Doug Shafer
Oh. No, no, no, I um, I left teaching ... I did it for two years, um ...
Lindy Novak
Were you in the Central Valley?
Doug Shafer
No, I was in Tucson, Arizona.
Lindy Novak
Tucson. Ah, okay.
Beth Novak
Yep.
Lindy Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
You guys didn't know that.
Beth Novak
No, I'd forgotten that.
Doug Shafer
Uh, but no, I left teaching because ... well, you know, Lindy, chats we've had about young and, you know, idealistic.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
That was me.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And I thought I was gonna be able to change the world through education.
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative). Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And within two years of teaching, it's like, "Oh man." You know, the kids are like, third on the list. It's the parents, it's the board of education.
Beth Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative), yes.
Doug Shafer
So I was very frustrated.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
From a very, um-
Lindy Novak
That's too bad.
Doug Shafer
... you know, altruistic view, viewpoint. And I still, you know, I, I had the degree in wine, grapes and wine, I still loved it so uh, I was home at Christmas break bef- my second year of teaching, and I actually said to Dad, I said ... you're gonna love this, I said, "I'm thinking about coming back and getting in the wine business." And he, and I quote, he said, "Well I don't have a job for you."
Lindy Novak
Oh my!
Beth Novak
(Laughs).
Doug Shafer
Oh, oh yeah!
Lindy Novak
That's inviting.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, that ... well it was fine because my retort was, and hon- very honestly said, "I don't want to work for you anyway, so no big deal."
Lindy Novak
(Laughs).
Doug Shafer
So, so that was fine. So I- because had a wine maker and -
Lindy Novak
Right.
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
So I came back and was ... I was doing my own thing.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
With, you know ...
Lindy Novak
But you, you guys have always been close, you and your Dad, right? Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Oh yeah. Well no, well that's, we have an honest relationship.
Lindy Novak
Yep.
Doug Shafer
You know.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And, and I wasn't looking for, I didn't want to work with him.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
You know, even, and the fact that we've ended up working for close to 40 years together is pretty amazing.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. So-
Doug Shafer
Because it was never, never even a thought.
Lindy Novak
So who did you end up working for?
Doug Shafer
I was working at uh, Lake Spring.
Lindy Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
It's now defunct, with Randy Mason.
Lindy Novak
Oh yes.
Doug Shafer
Who also was up at Chappellet.
Lindy Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
With Tony Soter.
Lindy Novak
Okay, okay.
Doug Shafer
Um, and was his uh, cellar rat slash assistant wine maker for two or three years.
Lindy Novak
Oh, okay.
Beth Novak
Lake Spring was on Spring Mountain?
Doug Shafer
Uh, Hoffman Lane. South of Yountville.
Lindy Novak
Oh, south of Yountville okay, okay, gotcha.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, yeah, that facility out there.
Beth Novak
Okay.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
And then how long til your dad let you come to work ?
Doug Shafer
Um, about three years with Randy and then his winemaker had some issues and then he called me up and said, "Do you want to come do this?"
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
So I said okay, we'll give it a try.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
He actually had to talk me into it.
Lindy Novak
Oh, he did?
Doug Shafer
Because I s- I said I'm, I ... (laughs) another quote, "I know enough to know I don't know how to do this yet."
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Beth Novak
Right, yeah.
Doug Shafer
And he said, "Well we'll get you con- some consulting help." And by the way, I was right.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
But we figured it out.
Lindy Novak
And you guys brought Tony on too at a certain point, yeah.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, I brought Tony on after three or four years,Ii brought Tony on.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, Tony's, Tony's amazing.
Doug Shafer
Tony was great.
Lindy Novak
Yep, yeah. Yeah.
Doug Shafer
So there you go. So you're ... you're in the world of clothing and sales, and Beth, you're ... you're in college.
Beth Novak
Right. So I graduated UCLA in '83 and I had lived my junior year abroad, so when I got out of, of college, I knew I wanted to, when I got done with UCLA, I knew I wanted to come to Northern California and live in the City. And I got a job with a wine brokerage actually, right out of college. I mean, I graduated and I was working the next week.
Doug Shafer
Were you, was the wine thing, when did the wine thing kick in for you?
Beth Novak
I think I got interested when I was living in Europe.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
I mean, we were drinking an awful lot of beer because I was in Salzburg, Austria, but-
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
Since I could legally drink, I've been reminded that I actually was the one that would order wine. Somehow or another this wine interest was kind of hitting me without my even really knowing it.
Doug Shafer
Huh.
Beth Novak
And I, and I also had brought wine to everybody at UCLA, um, the, my friends, we used to sit on the stairs (laughs) and drink wine.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
At the end of the semester, you know? I mean, why not, there's always an excuse, so um.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs).
Beth Novak
So anyway, somehow, I got out and I, I had interviewed before, I got a job with a man named Bruce McCumber who had brokerage called Bruce McCumber Wines, and it was amazing. So this was 1983.
Doug Shafer
I remember that.
Beth Novak
So you think about a time, you know, we had Joseph Phelps when Joseph Phelps used to make like, 20 different wines. From late harv- you know, from]
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
But a late harvest JR to early JR to carbonic zin, to ... I mean, they made everything.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
And we had, you know, Caymus was making wines that were, right from their estate and were like-
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
You know, just really lovely. Um, uh Saintsbury Pine Ridge, I mean, Dick, you know, Dick Ward and David Graves had just started Saintsbury.
Doug Shafer
Dick Ward.
Beth Novak
So it was a really interesting time to get .... we had more brands than that, but it was a great time to get into it, and then if you think about San Francisco at the time, you know, Stars had recently opened up, so you had the whole Jeremiah Tower thing going on. You know, obviously Chez Panisse had been open since the late 70s so there was a whole renaissance.
Doug Shafer
And you're living in, you're living in the City?
Beth Novak
Living in the City, actually with Lindy.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, for a while we lived together.
Beth Novak
Yeah, I moved, moved in with Lindy.
Doug Shafer
You two lived together? Wow.
Beth Novak
We did!
Doug Shafer
Wow, okay.
Lindy Novak
We lived together. We did, we got in a little fun trouble together for a while in North Beach.
Beth Novak
We did!
Lindy Novak
And Union Street, and ...
Doug Shafer
I think that's a reality show. We could do this.
Beth Novak
We could! It was, it was fun, I mean, Lindy and I have always gotten along really well.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Which is, which is really nice, I feel very lucky for that.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, yeah. Vice versa.
Beth Novak
Yeah, moved, moved to the City and uh, and sold wine for a number of years and then ultimately met John, who's now my husband, um, when, when I was there, and we quit our jobs and spent a whole summer, like three and a half months hiking and backpacking our way through the Pacific Northwest and ...
Doug Shafer
Ah.
Beth Novak
You know, Northern California, Oregon, Washington, up into Canada, back down, ultimately Wyoming and home.
Doug Shafer
Oh I never knew that.
Beth Novak
And that was great, and then I came back and uh, it was like, okay I need to learn more about computers, because PCs were just coming.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
So I did some temp work. I had no idea what I wanted to do, but I was doing temp work for different people and learning PC work, and then ultimately it was like, I'd like to get back in the wine business, I was trying to figure out how.
Doug Shafer
How to do it.
Beth Novak
And then at that time Mom, my mom called me and said, "Hey I could," it was uh, fall of '87 and suggested that she could use some help, and John and I were living together in sin, as she liked to remind me in San Francisco.
Lindy Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
Uh, my, my mom did the same thing.
Beth Novak
Ah, yeah, that kind of reminder thing.
Doug Shafer
We were living in sin, yeah.
Beth Novak
Yeah, it's like, ouch.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
So I came up a couple days a week, for probably two weeks and literally it just turned into full time, so I came on-
Doug Shafer
So that's '87 so ... the Spottswoode-
Beth Novak
'87 so we were releasing our '84
Doug Shafer
The first Spottswoode wine was an '82 vintage which came out-
Beth Novak
'82, so we were releasing our third vintage.
Doug Shafer
Got it, okay.
Beth Novak
And, and uh, and it was, and it was, and at that time Tony had become our vineyard manager in '85, so, and he had brought organic farming to the property then.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
And so, and so it was really just, I mean, our mom was doing all of the, I mean, she was doing payroll which she hated. She was doing all this stuff, administratively which was a hundred percent not her thing, yeah.
Doug Shafer
She was doing everything.
Beth Novak
She was doing, what was it?
Lindy Novak
More or less everything, To- Tony was helping her.
Beth Novak
Handwritten invoices and ...
Lindy Novak
Handwritten invoices, it was hilarious.
Beth Novak
yeah.
Lindy Novak
So she was very happy to have-
Doug Shafer
Handwritten checks, fax machines.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Well fax machines probably weren't even, they weren't even there.
Lindy Novak
No, no fax machine.
Beth Novak
No.
Lindy Novak
She did want to invest in a fax machine she felt like it was a waste of money. It's like, Mom?
Doug Shafer
I kind of remember those days. We-
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
I remember it took us a while to get one too.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, it's like, "Mom, we gotta make the investment." But she didn't want to do that.
Beth Novak
Finally got the printer.
Doug Shafer
Do the kids, do our kids know what a fax machine is? I don't think they do.
Beth Novak
They probably don't.
Doug Shafer
I should-
Lindy Novak
Yeah, maybe not.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
They may not. They may not.
Doug Shafer
Alright, kids, if you're listening we'll, we'll chat at Christmas.
Beth Novak
Exactly, exactly.
Lindy Novak
That's right. So you guys took over the upstairs of the house, all the, the kids had vacated and ...
Doug Shafer
Oh is it, okay.
Beth Novak
Yep, that's where our offices were.
Doug Shafer
Oh, so, so, that's all, oh okay.
Beth Novak
So we were custom crushing outside, bringing the barrels back to Spottswoode to age.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
Then taking the wine back out to Sequoia Grove to bottle.
Lindy Novak
In the basement.
Doug Shafer
And you used to age them in the basement, because I remember seeing down there.
Lindy Novak
Yep.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
For some reason I was over there trying to wine with somebody, Tony.
Beth Novak
Probably with Tony. And yeah, everything, everything was down in the basement.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, everything was in the basement of the house.
Beth Novak
Exactly. And it smelled good.
Doug Shafer
Cool.
Beth Novak
And then the offices were upstairs. And so, we had everything up there and then, and then ultimately, um, our mom at first I think thought that she wouldn't mind the activity at our house, because she was alone.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
And so she was like, "Okay, this will be fine." And then she quickly realized, "No, I don't want people coming up my front stairs and looking in the window and knocking on the door and asking where Spottswoode is." So we started thinking about where are we gonna go?
Doug Shafer
Your, your new customers, your fans.
Lindy Novak
That's right.
Beth Novak
Yeah, we kinda need, yeah, we kinda need a home, and uh ...
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
And so then luckily this property across the street came on the market. We didn't actually know about it, it was Dan Duckhorn that knew about it, it was a beaut- let's see, um, beautiful old stone building which is the 19th pre-Prohibition winery in Napa County.
Doug Shafer
Whoa. And it'd been sitting there forever vacant, it was right - It was a tool shed.
Beth Novak
It had been sitting there, it was just, yeah tractor equipment and it was Ken [inaudible 00:36:38] property, and, and then the old farmhouse which is now our offices. So um, Dan Duckhorn made an offer, bought it, and what he, they wanted was the vineyard land because they knew that they weren't gonna keep getting grapes from us, because we were gonna be ... we were making our own wine and-
Doug Shafer
Yeah, making your own wine.
Beth Novak
Ultimately we'll be replanting because of phylloxera. So he wanted to continue to get grapes from that side, we wanted the building, so luckily we figured out a way to parcel off the front two acres and so we got the, the buildings and he got the seven and a half acres of vineyard behind and we ended up moving up there.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, completely refurbished the house.
Doug Shafer
No, no, it's beautiful.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, it's a neat place.
Beth Novak
Looks like a mini-Spottswoode. They're, don't they look related?
Doug Shafer
It's ... no it's great.
Lindy Novak
A little bit.
Doug Shafer
Well what's nice is you've got all your ... you, you crush there, you press there, all your production.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Exactly. Since '99 you know, we didn't-
Doug Shafer
Since '99.
Lindy Novak
We didn't have the financial ability. We had the whole thing mapped out so that we could build the production facility. And then at the same time that we bought the property and fixed up the barrel building first and then the office building, we ... phylloxera showed up, which we had anticipated.
Doug Shafer
I was gonna ask you about that.
Lindy Novak
But we took the decade of the 90s to replant our vineyard, and then once we got ahead of that, that's where our financial resources went was the vineyard. Once we were ahead of that, then we're like, okay, now it is time to build a, a facility here.
And then what pushed us hard on that too was that '98 vintage, remember how hot it was? And um-
Doug Shafer
Oh yeah.
Beth Novak
(Laughs) it was a hot vintage, and, and Rosemary Cakebread who was making our wines at the time was scrambling to find space, because we were out in Napa Wine Company and we had to clear tanks and Tony Soter was nice enough to take us down to his facility and, and on Oak Knoll and let us do some more extended.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
And it was like, we can't keep doing this. So we, we had been in the planning stages, but we started um, we started construction in '98 and it was ready for the '99 harvest.
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Beth Novak
Yeah, so that was nice.
Lindy Novak
And wasn't it one of Howard Backen's early projects?
Beth Novak
It was Howard Backen's first, yeah, he was, he was willing to do it for us just because he wanted to get his foot in the door for ... a wine- for building wineries.
Doug Shafer
Oh you got, you got a Howard Backen -
Beth Novak
We have a Howard Backen winery, but we got it for extremely cheap.
Doug Shafer
Congratulations. Way to go.
Beth Novak
Yeah, early on. Yeah.
Doug Shafer
So ... you got done in time for the '99 harvest.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
That's great. And phylloxera was a tough one, that took us all down.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
That was ... so that was, you were taking care of that in the early, mid 90s.
Beth Novak
In the early 90s, basically. We started in 1990 so we had that ... Tony had come to my mom and me in, in '88 basically and said, "Look, if phylloxera is out there," and you'll remember Doug that there was so much denial about phylloxera. I mean, if you remember, even like, Opus One had just planted that whole vineyard in front of their winery on Highway 29.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
With AXR-1 stock in the late 80s. So people were kind of like, there was a sense of denial about it, but Tony was like, "I've seen it, it's out there, we're going to get it."
Doug Shafer
It's out there.
Beth Novak
We're on AXR-1.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
David Abreu was the one who was farming our vineyard with, with uh, Tony, because he had the equipment, so you- I mean, who knows who gave what to whom, it's just that ... it's just that ...
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
We were spreading it around through driving equipment in and out of different vineyards. We would've gotten it anyway, it doesn't matter, so Tony had already uh, determined and come to my mom and me and said, "Look, when we find it we need to have a plan, and the plan, I think should be-"
Doug Shafer
Okay, fine, right.
Beth Novak
"... we're gonna sacrifice the sauvignon blanc acreage for cabernet."
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
So when we discovered it was out in the back acreage, you know, the part of the vineyard that, that was kind of the prime
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Beth Novak
And still is that acreage that you wanted to buy from too, out in the back
Doug Shafer
(Laughs) always.
Beth Novak
And so that's where we found it and so we took out that, we took out the sauvignon blanc in 1990 after the '90 harvest and started replanting in '91.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, that was kind of a heartbreaker for Mom. She loved, she loves sauvignon blanc, she doesn't ... never was as, as much as a fan of cabernet as sauvignon blanc.
Doug Shafer
Did you ever, did you ever replant sauvignon blanc?
Beth Novak
We have one acre, 1.07 acres out there. Mary's Block, it's named for her.
Doug Shafer
Good.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Good for you.
Beth Novak
Yeah. That started purchasing sauvignon blanc. At that point.
Doug Shafer
You know I ... I, you just, I just thought of something. I've got a ... this has no rhyme or reason to anything we're talking about, but I just flashed on your grapes and the six or seven years we had the Spottswoode tank here in this cellar.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
Because we, we kept everything separate.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And let me tell you guys something, well you know it, but I'm going to tell it to you. That Spottswoode tank was always like ... ah, so good. It was really good. And, and it was-
Beth Novak
That's nice, thanks.
Doug Shafer
It was good and it, and it was, what was neat was it was really different than the, the cab off this property.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
And it was different from other cabs that we purch- were purchasing at the time. But there was just this amazingly sleek, racy ...clear, clear as a bell fruit.
Beth Novak
Yeah, precision, yeah there's something about it.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Precision, precision.
Beth Novak
Like delineation, yeah.
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Doug Shafer
And we loved it. So I was, and it-
Beth Novak
Yeah. That's good to know.
Lindy Novak
Thank you.
Beth Novak
Thank you.
Doug Shafer
And it shows today in the wines you bottle.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
But I just had a-
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Because when you're ... when you make wine, you're in the cellar, you um ... you get really intimate with your tanks at harvest time.
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
Because you know that, you know, tank eight is the Spottswoode tank, and tank nine is, you know, upper seven, and tank thing, you know it's just-
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
And you just, you kinda know them because you're, you're tasting them two or three times each day.
Beth Novak
You hug them occasionally.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, hug them, yeah.
Lindy Novak
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
Show me love.
Doug Shafer
I mean you um, you kinda-
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
It's hard to describe.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
It's probably the one thing I miss most about not being in a real-
Beth Novak
Yes, mm-hmm (affirmative).
Doug Shafer
... hands-on day to day wine maker anymore.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
But um, boy that Spottswoode tank was always great.
Lindy Novak
That's nice.
Beth Novak
Thank you for saying so.
Doug Shafer
So, okay, so you're cranking along, what ... Lindy, when do you, when do you get involved?
Lindy Novak
Uh, so I was, as mentioned I was, uh, still traveling and uh, selling uh, swimwear. And uh-
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Lindy Novak
Yeah. And it, it was fun. I mean I, I lived in, I had moved to Marin and I was, I, I got to write swimwear orders in the winter and all the shipments happened in the summer and I'd be windsurfing over the summer, so windsurfing and swimsuits all went together.
Doug Shafer
Nice.
Lindy Novak
So that was fun. Uh, but I'd been selling for a number of years, and one year I was hanging up my samples and I wasn't feeling quite as enthusiastic about it, as I had in the past.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
Um, business was changing, you- um, we sort of touched on what retail has become today, it was becoming more competitive, more uh, deal-driven and retailers were negotiating with you-
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
... for profitability, and that part of it I didn't really think was very much fun. So um, I was hanging up samples and thinking, "Hm, I don't know, I'm not as excited about this as I once was." And so somehow you and Mom and I started chatting, and uh, Beth and Mom said, "Well why don't you just come up? You have the flexibility. Uh, you have to get off your windsurf board for a little while."
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Lindy Novak
"But come up and, and see if you uh, you know, work, work part time at the winery and see if you have, if you feel any uh, uh, inclination toward it." And I always say it would make a lovely story if I could say, oh my god I just thought it seemed so fascinating. It, it was ... it seemed interesting, but it was gonna involve a, uh, taking a risk on my part.
Doug Shafer
Right, right.
Lindy Novak
And I'm not a huge risk-taker, but I thought, well, I either keep doing what I'm doing and, or I, I take a risk, and I felt like I was close enough with mom and Beth so that if it didn't work out, we could be honest with one another.
Beth Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Doug Shafer
Yeah, that's important.
Lindy Novak
And say, "It's probably not a ... it's not a fit." So I would say um, it was uh, what was, it, it was hard because didn't know very much about wine, I was still going to bars in, in the City and drinking you know, vodka.
Doug Shafer
(Laughs)
Beth Novak
Keoke coffees.
Lindy Novak
Keoke coffees, vodka cranberries.
Doug Shafer
There you go.
Beth Novak
(Laughs).
Lindy Novak
You know, whatever, whatever.
Doug Shafer
[inaudible 00:43:52]
Beth Novak
Greyhounds.
Lindy Novak
Uh, that's probably the stronger the better.
Beth Novak
(Laughs)
Lindy Novak
And so uh, I didn't know much about wine.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
And uh, fortunately for me at that time, uh, we ended up hiring Pam Starr.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
To make our wines.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
And so uh, you know, she's a powerhouse of energy and she's very ebullient and uh, uh, loves wine. So when we would travel together selling wine, uh, I had the sales experience from swimwear, she could talk about the wine and I could tell the family story.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
So it worked out very nicely.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
And so I kind of grew into the role and uh, started out hand- handling our California sales and then eventually um, uh, grew into taking over some out of state markets from Beth and um, uh, became uh, oh, I started, I, uh, eventually oversaw national sales. So um, it was it, it, it's been fun.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Lindy Novak
I got to travel the country.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, well you-
Lindy Novak
I've gotten to meet amazing people.
Beth Novak
Yeah, you've built great relationships with a lot of our people and that's important.
Lindy Novak
Thank you, well I like that part of it, I do.
Doug Shafer
Well I remember one trip, and I think you were both on it.
Lindy Novak
Yep.
Doug Shafer
So you were probably, you know, it was in the early stages. It was the uh, Washington DC-
Beth Novak
I was gonna say, the MacArthur Tasting.
Doug Shafer
Mac- the MacArthur Tasting.
Beth Novak
Oh yes (laughs), yeah.
Doug Shafer
But one night, we had a free night and our distributor, um ...
Beth Novak
[Bacchus 00:45:09], John [Mantis 00:45:11] yeah.
Doug Shafer
John [Mantis 00:45:12] from the bus. And it was you guys, me, Cathy Corison.
Beth Novak
Tony Soter.
Doug Shafer
Tony Soter.
Beth Novak
Oh god, where did we go?
Lindy Novak
Well Sam [Citron 00:45:19] was with us.
Doug Shafer
We, we had the big plan was we were gonna take off at, um ... it was 5:30 or 6:00 and we were gonna hit four or five accounts.
Lindy Novak
That's right.
Beth Novak
Oh yes.
Doug Shafer
And we were all gonna go in and like, have a course of each account with all five or six of us.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
And each, you know ... having a-
Beth Novak
That's right.
Doug Shafer
... pouring our wine for the wine bar at each establishment.
Beth Novak
Yes, yes.
Lindy Novak
Oh my god.
Doug Shafer
It was a hoot.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Because we were just, you know, it was a road trip.
Beth Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
And we were riding around, ride- just, but it was-
Beth Novak
(Laughs) Exactly, in DC.
Doug Shafer
But it was only like a mile between stops.
Lindy Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
We went to um ... oh god, where did we go, um ...
Beth Novak
We probably went to Red Sage there, Kincaid's?
Lindy Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
Kincai- went to Kincaid's, Red Sage.
Lindy Novak
Did we go to[Nora maybe?
Doug Shafer
Nora we probably hit.
Beth Novak
Uh-huh, we might have gone to Nora.
Doug Shafer
And the last stop was Michael Sternberg's ... Lindy and I couldn't remember the name.
Lindy Novak
The name of the steakhouse.
Doug Shafer
The steakhouse.
Beth Novak
Oh.
Lindy Novak
Yes. I'm going to have to think about that, mm-hmm (affirmative). Yeah.
Doug Shafer
It was on K Street or L Street. Anyway, Lindy, you know, I knew, I've known Beth forever because, you know, and then Lindy I didn't know that well, so I'm getting to know her.
Lindy Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
And so all of a sudden at one- you know, we're third or fourth stop, she says something about cookies.
Lindy Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
I said, "What do you mean?" She goes, "Doesn't a cookie and a glass of milk sound really good?"
Beth Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
And I was like, "Wow, I never thought about that. And you know? It does sound really good." I wasn't telling her, this is my, my mind thinking.
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
But it does sound really good because I've just been drinking wine, you know, my own wine, all day long and ... and fancy food. God, cookies and a glass of milk.
Lindy Novak
It sounded good.
Beth Novak
I think better.
Doug Shafer
So all of a sudden, I said, yeah. I said, you know, I didn't now who this woman was, but I said-
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
"This sounds like a really good idea."
Lindy Novak
(Laughs)
Doug Shafer
So, so I started jumping on that too. So the next two stops we kept asking for milk and cookies and no one had it until the last stop. We said, and boom, we each have a big glass of milk and some warm chocolate chip cookies.
Lindy Novak
Warm cookies.
Beth Novak
Oh, nothing quite like that.
Lindy Novak
No.
Beth Novak
That's good.
Doug Shafer
So whenever Lindy and I see each other on the road-
Lindy Novak
It's about cookies.
Doug Shafer
No matter where, we always have to have warm cookies.
Beth Novak
About warm cookies and milk, I love it.
Doug Shafer
Warm cookies and milk.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I told Doug that I've just now discovered, uh, Danny Meyer's Shake Shack frozen yogurt with caramel sauce on top, and that's a close second to those warm chocolate chip cookies, I must say.
Beth Novak
Oh I've not had that. But Danny Meyer knows to, how to do it.
Lindy Novak
He does.
Doug Shafer
He knows how to do it.
Beth Novak
He does.
Lindy Novak
He's got the touch.
Doug Shafer
Alright, so quickly, the Spottswoode grapes, which I talked about, and the quality of that wine from that site, um, but you've had ... talk to me, because you've had uh, a number of winemakers through the years.
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Doug Shafer
... I would be, I, I think uh, everybody would love to hear who they were because I can't keep them all straight. They start out with Tony.
Beth Novak
So Tony from '82 through '91.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Beth Novak
Mia Klein sort of came to work with him in '90, because we were crushing our fruit down at, at um Robert Pepi, present day Cardinale.
Doug Shafer
Right, right.
Beth Novak
So that's how they got introduced. Then Pam Starr came on board with us in '92, and Tony consulted, Tony and Mia consulted.
Doug Shafer
Got it.
Beth Novak
'92 through '96, and then Rosemary Cakebread came on board with us in '97, Tony consulted for one year and then was kind of getting, moving on his way to Oregon.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
He's making great pinot up there, which I buy every year.
Doug Shafer
Yep.
Beth Novak
Um, and so Rosemary Cakebread came on in '97, and then she made the wines through '05, at which time Jennifer Williams, whom she had hired as an assistant winemaker came on as a winemaker, and then ultimately in ... well January of '11, so really he finished the '10 vintage, Aaron Weinkauf who had been our assistant winemaker and vineyard manager start- took over the wine making.
Doug Shafer
So quite a string of really good winemakers.
Beth Novak
Yes. Yeah.
Doug Shafer
What's the ... because you guys run it, I mean what's your ... how do you, how do you work with different winemakers and you know, they might want this, they might want that, and they've got this great vineyard I mean, do you have to kinda like, "Here's our style and this is what we're sticking to?" Or is it a collaboration of, you know, someone's got a new idea? I mean ... because I, I, I don't have that.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, no, it's a, it's a, it's a- (laughs).
Doug Shafer
I'm stuck, I'm stuck with one winemaker. I mean 35 years, I mean jeez.
Beth Novak
Right, which is a great thing. And I, and I went to, and I went to high school with Elias we were on track.
Doug Shafer
And ai ai ai and on and on and on.
Beth Novak
We were on track team together. Um ...
Doug Shafer
That's right. You and Elias.
Beth Novak
Elias and I, yeah, we were, we were in high school together. Yeah, you know, I mean, for us I think what we've always done is that any time a new winemaker has come on we go through an entire vertical of the wines.
Doug Shafer
Okay. Smart.
Beth Novak
We talk about the property, we talk about what we're looking for. Uh, we're talking about always wanting to make a wine that honors the estate, and speaks to the time and place, ev- you know, each year shows its vintage and its site. And so we've spoken about that, certainly there was times, I mean, there had been changes when, when um ... I mean, with the replant of course, that caused some change.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
Because now we have different root stocks and different things going on. Um ...
Doug Shafer
Yeah, we have the same thing.
Beth Novak
And then ... and then there was the time when, when people were getting, you know, when things were getting a little bit riper, and, and it was kinda like ... and that's what the press was, was uh, was-
Lindy Novak
Loving.
Beth Novak
Loving.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
And so-
We certainly, we- we never went as far as some, but we went riper than we had been, um, probably I think 14-7 or 14-8 has been literally our highest alcohol.
Doug Shafer
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Beth Novak
But we've- we've brought that back, with, with Aaron, and so, and that was late nine- I would say '09 was probably our, our-
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
Sort of most open, and it's showing beautifully right now, by the way.
Lindy Novak
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Doug Shafer
Yes.
Beth Novak
But it- it was probably that one where it was like wait a minute, now we're kind- are we losing what we think is Spottswoode-esque, you know? And I don't, I don't know that we were, but we, we made a conscious decision to kind of like, "Oh let's, let's pull that back."
Doug Shafer
Well you have to. That's important.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
Because your customers count on it.
Beth Novak
Yeah, that's right.
Doug Shafer
And that's what- that's what we found.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
That they, they, yeah, they wanna know like it's gonna be a certain style.
Beth Novak
That's right, exactly. Exactly. They buy Shafer because they love that style.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
And that's, and that's, and if you all of the sudden just changed it, it would be like, "Ooh, that's not what I had in mind." All right?
Lindy Novak
Right.
Beth Novak
So, yeah. So it's, it's, it's been ... we, we've been able to do that. We've been able to keep that on, on track.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, there's been-
Beth Novak
Just been fun.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Nice consistency. I think people, uh, often when they taste a vertical, they try to peg, "Oh, is this where Pam left off? And this is where Rosemary started." I don't think you can really-
Doug Shafer
I just-
Lindy Novak
Yeah, there might be a tiny bit of, of winemaker influence, that makes sense. But it's- there's consistency.
Doug Shafer
That's a- that's a small percentage of people.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, yeah.
Doug Shafer
Yeah. Yeah.
Lindy Novak
But they try.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
So current lineup these days, you've got Cabernet, Cabernet Sauvignon-
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
Spottswoode label.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And Spottswoode label, you've also got Sauvignon Blanc.
Beth Novak
Correct.
Lindy Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
And that's it on the Spottswoode label?
Beth Novak
That's it on the Spottswoode label.
Doug Shafer
And then the second label is ... is there a second label or just a different brand?
Beth Novak
It's a Napa Valley Cabernet, so it's Lyndenhurst Cabernet Sauvignon, and it's Napa Valley, a little bit from our estate. And then, um, and then we do purchase a bit from the outside. So that's a couple thousand cases a year literally. And then Spottswoode Cabernet, our goal every year is 4,000 cases. We hope to hit that. Sometimes we do, sometimes we don't. Sometimes we're a bit over, but we, that's where we want to be. And then about 4,000 cases of Spottswoode sauvignon blanc. We're about a 10,000 case winery. And those are real numbers. Those aren't like, those are actually what we're producing.
Doug Shafer
I'm with you, um, you know, I've, come on you guys. (Laughter)
Beth Novak
I mean that because there is, there's a lot of times when people say what their production is, and you're like, "Really? Is this ..." I mean, you know, there's, there's-
Doug Shafer
Oh, you know, you know-
Beth Novak
People assume that small production is better.
Doug Shafer
I get the same thing. I run into like John Williams-
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
Great friend.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
He just like, "Yeah, right Shafer-
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
"Yeah right. You're all over the place." (Laughter) It's like, "Come on John, give me a break. You guys, look at you." I said, "No, we just, you know, we just do a lot of PR and stuff. We're talking about it."
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
"You know, you gotta be 80,000 cases." No we're not.
Lindy Novak
Yeah,.
Beth Novak
Right. Exactly.
Doug Shafer
I know people like to do that.
Beth Novak
Yeah, people always think that we're bigger than we are just because the name has some-
Doug Shafer
It's a nice size.
Beth Novak
And that would be true for you. It is a nice size.
Doug Shafer
But you saw, but you saw, how many states are you guys in?
Beth Novak
Almost all. All.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Except for North Dakota we just reopened Oklahoma and I think considering going back into Arkansas, is that right? And that just, that just evolved even with our small production 'cause we would have people requesting our wines and after a certain point we kind of couldn't say no.
Beth Novak
Yeah, we're doing a lot internationally too. So we're at about 12% and I, I see that growing to be, be 15 to 20%.
Doug Shafer
That's great.
Beth Novak
We've grown that from 5%. So we feel like that international exposure and kind of having that broad distribution is, is why it's long term.
Doug Shafer
We're on the same page on that one.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
So your biggest export markets?
Beth Novak
Ooh right now would be Belgium is actually really big.
Doug Shafer
Wow.
Beth Novak
Hong Kong is very good.
Doug Shafer
Hong Kong's great.
Beth Novak
Japan is actually a little bit bigger than, than Hong Kong. Uh, England, so, is good. So all of those markets are probably our base. Germany is also good.
Doug Shafer
Good. We need to compare notes on-
Beth Novak
We do.
Doug Shafer
Importers.
Beth Novak
Yes.
Doug Shafer
'Cause you know some, you know they, they move. You know, they move-
Beth Novak
Yeah, exactly.
Doug Shafer
And you've got to keep your eye open.
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
We'll do that. We'll do that offline. (Laughter) Um, so you two and your mom, a lot of years together. How many years together?
Lindy Novak
87 to 16 for me. So is that almost 40? '87, '97, '07, '17-
Doug Shafer
What's the secret? What's the secret?
Lindy Novak
30 years I guess.
Doug Shafer
How did that work for 30 years?
Beth Novak
I mean, for mom and me, I don't know. I mean, you know, we never, I have to say like, we never argued. We never, I don't know what the secret was. I think the secret might've been as that and Lindy can chime in, chime in on this, but she really didn't want to have control. She really wasn't ... like she was, she was happy to, to give that up, you know what I mean? So she wasn't constantly trying to hang on to something. And so overtime she, she stayed engaged to the extent that she would know what was happening financially and would take a look at the financials and we'd go over them. And that was important to her to know that it was successful. But then beyond that she was trusting, which was really nice.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Beth Novak
She trusted us to make the right decisions and, and to have her and our best interests at heart. So I don't, I don't know. I mean, the only time I really got mad at her was when she, we had coyotes out in the vineyard and this was probably like eight years ago, and she brought in like somebody who was going to maybe try to take these coyotes out. And I just said, absolutely not. That person needs to go away. They, they're not our coyotes. They belong to, you know, this environment. And we will not, we will not, they're not ours to, to, to, to do anything about. They're not, they're not hurting us. So that was probably the only time where I just really put my foot down and said that board is not doing that here. We're not going to trap these coyotes and have them-
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
Take them somewhere. And that was, and, you know, I just, and that was really probably a function of my mom just thinking, "Well, maybe they're not good to have here. You know, we would want them here." It wasn't like, she's not a nice person. She just felt like they shouldn't be here, but honestly, we had no ... And we had more fun traveling. I mean, I took a ton of trips with mom.
Lindy Novak
So did I.
Beth Novak
Lindy did, and she was great.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Pretty, pretty, uh, not easy going is the right word, but you know, not, uh, just, uh, really, uh, of course we're both biased. But you know, a great person, really nice. The, the Mary Novak that you drank coffee with in the kitchen sort of never, never left. And, uh, and she never really wanted the limelight either. So that left, uh, left Beth and I, you know, she never wanted to really speak at engagements.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
You remember how nervous she would get-
Beth Novak
Oh she would get terribly nervous.
Lindy Novak
She didn't want to get up and talk in front of groups and, um, uh, but, uh, one on one, you know, people, people loved her. They, they always used to say it like right. She'd be standing next to me, and you know, we'd be visiting with some people in the yard and people would say, "Your mother is such a treasure." You know, as if she wasn't even standing right there. I mean, people just ... I think her down to earthness, uh, you know, she was just a, a good person. A good sense of humor and-
Beth Novak
Yeah, yeah.
Lindy Novak
Good sense of adventure and um, uh, yeah. I mean, people would come by and she'd invite them out on the porch for wine. I, I hear that story everywhere I go.
Beth Novak
I do too. I do too.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, she would just, she would invite anybody over. I remember that.
Lindy Novak
I mean, if they were out here-
Beth Novak
I don't think she was that nice to us.
Lindy Novak
I don't either. (Laughter)
Beth Novak
No, she was.
Lindy Novak
No, she was, she was. Yeah, uh, really, uh, I mean, your dad kind of reminds me of mom, you know? I, in terms of down to earthness, being a real person, uh-
Doug Shafer
And, and always, you know, very interested in other people. What they do and how they got to where they got to.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Right.
Doug Shafer
It's like, tell me your story. It's kind of like what we do here.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Beth Novak
Yes, exactly.
Doug Shafer
And it's really kind of neat.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And uh, I had a similar thing with dad, Just um, just like he trusted me.
Lindy Novak
Yes.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
I was like, I'm thinking, you know, wow!
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Because when you grow up with them, you know they're your parents for all those years, it's like you know, when did, when did switch from me being the kid to like-
Beth Novak
Right, yeah.
Doug Shafer
A young adult, you know?
Beth Novak
Exactly.
Doug Shafer
You know, I mean a trustworthy adult.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
I'm still not sure.
Beth Novak
Yeah, that's right.
Lindy Novak
That's right.
Doug Shafer
Oh, she was a sweetheart-
Lindy Novak
Yeah, thanks.
Doug Shafer
We, we lost her three years ago.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Yup.
Doug Shafer
How do you think she'd want to be remembered?
Lindy Novak
Do you want to start?
Beth Novak
Uh-
Doug Shafer
You each got a shot. You each got a mic.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, right. Uh, no, you go first.
Beth Novak
I mean, I think she'd want to be remembered as, as, for, for who she was in her, in her heart and her soul, which was just a person who, yeah, who cared deeply about what she did. Cared, cared a lot about Spottswoode. Um, had family in her, in her mind. I mean, she was very family oriented. She loved to travel. I mean, she just, she, she, she did what she believed in. She didn't do what she thought people wanted her to do or what she thought she would do.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
She was genuine. She was authentic and true to herself.
Doug Shafer
Pretty genuine.
Beth Novak
And I think, I think that's what she'd want to be remembered for.
Doug Shafer
Yeah. Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Yeah, I, I would agree with that. And probably, you know, for her, a little bit for her sense of humor, for her bridge playing skills. She was an excellent-
Doug Shafer
Oh, I didn't know that.
Lindy Novak
She was cagey.
Beth Novak
Yup, very.
Lindy Novak
She was a sneaky uh, competitor, you know-
Beth Novak
I mean, she was honest, but she, but she liked to win.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Yeah, she did. So she played with, with Barbara Shafer.
Doug Shafer
Barbara and my dad's wife-
Lindy Novak
and um, Diane Livingston and Betty O'shaughnessy.
Beth Novak
That's right.
Lindy Novak
And a contingent of women still come to the house-
Beth Novak
Monthly.
Lindy Novak
Uh, monthly and play bridge kind of in her honor. And there's usually also a-
Doug Shafer
Oh, play.
Beth Novak
Yeah, they play in mom's house, which is nice.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. There's a jigsaw puzzle often on the table that she worked a, a lot of. I think that's partly how she kept herself sharp. So there, there's always a-
Beth Novak
Crossword puzzles.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Well, maybe we should start a monthly thing, you know, I don't think we'll do bridge, but why don't I get the bumper-
Lindy Novak
We could do cookies.
Doug Shafer
I'll get the, we'll do bumper pool and cookies.
Lindy Novak
I'm liking the bumper pool idea.
Doug Shafer
I'll get the bumper pool.
Beth Novak
That would be awesome.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And then we can have contest.
Beth Novak
Okay. Sounds good.
Doug Shafer
We can play for cookies.
Beth Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Good.
Beth Novak
All right.
Doug Shafer
So, so currently what's going on? Who's ... roles, Beth, you're president?
Beth Novak
Yes, I run, I run the business.
Doug Shafer
You run the business?
Beth Novak
Yup.
Doug Shafer
Lindy is national sales.
Lindy Novak
I have been national sales and I, um, I'm uh, pulling back a little bit to become more ambassadorial. So we've hired uh, Susan Citron who, you know, Sam-
Doug Shafer
Oh, Susan yeah.
Lindy Novak
To help us on the east coast.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, she's great.
Lindy Novak
She's great. She lives in Pittsburgh and uh, she's very why knowledgeable and has a good business sense. And so she'd get any- anywhere in that neck of the woods in, you know, an hour and a half, which is awesome. And then Mary Pat Sullivan, who came to us from Chappellet four years ago?
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
I think it's been at least four years. Yeah.
Lindy Novak
She's great. And, uh, so she took over mid-western states and I was, uh, I kept six western states that I've kind of uh, turning over to her right now. And, um, I still would like to travel and be involved in, uh, some of the winery marketing. And I think that's really what I'm, I'm best at, is interacting with people out in the marketplace. I was just in Palm Desert and did a dinner with the Shin. A little group of the Shin, I was very intimated-
Beth Novak
Did they have
Lindy Novak
They were wearing all their metals, and their, their, yes, yes.
Beth Novak
So dorky, that's so funny. (Laughter)
Doug Shafer
Maybe Lindy's good with that. She can, she can run with it.
Beth Novak
Absolutely, she took her own -
Doug Shafer
Yeah.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. I want one, I want one of those. They're called ribbons and you, you accumulate-
Doug Shafer
Oh, I see it's a, it's a contest.
Lindy Novak
Pins by you know, the number of events that you participate in.
Beth Novak
We got to get going on that.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Yeah. So, um, you know, in the sales environment, you know, this from being out there in the world, has gotten more and more competitive and a lot of changes with distributors and it's a, uh, kind of a lot to keep up with. Uh, but um, so anyway, so I'm going to stay on in, in that capacity. And I mentioned to you Doug, when I saw your Red Shoulder Ranch artwork in the hallway that I just wrote a children's book.
Doug Shafer
Oh, I didn't know.
Lindy Novak
I've written several children's books for fun. I don't have any children, but I love to write. And mom used to write poems and she got me started on rhyming and kind of doctor Seuss, Seuss-ish rhyming so-
Doug Shafer
Children's book, when did you start doing this?
Lindy Novak
It's, it's taken a while to actually get a book into print. Probably, I probably been working on books for, I'm gonna say eight-ish years. And this particular one, one of my nieces, my brother Mike's, uh, and sister-in-law Mia's daughter Poppy is very artistic. She's, she did a, uh, a logo for the Farmer's Market St. Helena, she did the little shaft.
Doug Shafer
Okay.
Lindy Novak
She did the illustrations for it. So it's a rhyming book. And uh, what's interesting, it was really fun to have it come into fruition and have printed copies of it. And you know, I've had 200 printed and sold 150 and had book signing parties. But now it, it's like in the world of wine marketing, if you really want it to become something a little larger, I'm going to have to market it. So I'm trying to decide-
Doug Shafer
How fun.
Lindy Novak
What kind of commitment level I want to devote to that. And I, I'm also would like to take on some, um, little more environmental focus with the winery. You know, we have, Beth has been amazing with that organically farmed vineyard, solar panels, biodynamics. We're part of 1% for the planet, which is Yvon Chouinard's Patagonia group. And I'm very interested in the environment. I'm worried about the planet and I pick up trash in our neighborhood.
That sounds silly, but it's, I, I just would like to somehow, you know, kind of look at our donations and hone what, uh, groups are, are really important and, you know, could I go listen to some, uh, union of concerned scientists' lectures and things like that makes me feel, uh, if I could, you know, like you're going back to your school teaching, if we could do something beneficial for the planet above and beyond how we're treating the property that we're giving money to environmental charities, that would feel really good. So-
Doug Shafer
Great to hear.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Thanks.
Doug Shafer
So I got to ask you, because we have people writing into the podcast, sending us emails. Everybody wants to know, what do you guys drink at home?
Lindy Novak
Oh, what do we drink at home?
Doug Shafer
In the wine department. (Laughter) Well, actually you could open it up, I mean -
Lindy Novak
Milk and cookies of course. Yeah.
Doug Shafer
Yeah, milk. Milk of course.
Beth Novak
Yeah, you know, I mean, we drink, we drink a lot of, a lot of different wine. I mean I love, I love wines from Spain, whether it's, whether it's [inaudible 00:13:17] or whether it's from Rioja. I like the more, I drink more, sort of unique wines from here. Maybe Massa Ken or I like, you know, the Lang & Reed. We like uh, the Cabarnet Franc is really nice. Um, I love Rosé. I mean, we drink Lorenza Rosé, you know, Mindy, Melinda Kearney line we're talking of.
Doug Shafer
That's right. Yes, that's good wine.
Beth Novak
Um, and of course we, it's just trying a lot of different, a lot of different things. You know, Pi- Pinot Noir, I love those wines and uh, Jasmine Hirsch's wines. There's just a lot of great wine out there and it's just fun to taste these things and see what, what people are doing. So we drink a lot of things.
Doug Shafer
Good. Lindy, anything special?
Lindy Novak
I'm probably a little less adventurous than, than Beth is, uh, but I do love Rosé. I'll drink other Sauvignon blancs, um, primarily California Sauvignon blancs. I like some foreign wines, but not, not, not quite as, I'm not quite as fond as of the earthier more sophisticated uh, flavor profile honestly.
Doug Shafer
Fair enough.
Beth Novak
Not more sophisticated, but yeah, yeah.
Lindy Novak
A little but maybe not as fruit forward. You know, I have a sweet tooth. You go back to the chocolate chip cookies, I do. Uh, and I love Pinot Noir. Um, so in terms of a red wine, I would say that that's probably, that would probably get my vote for favorite.
Doug Shafer
All right.
Lindy Novak
No particular producer.
Doug Shafer
Good to know.
Lindy Novak
Yeah.
Doug Shafer
And if people want to find Spottswoode wine, what's the best way?
Beth Novak
Best way, if you want to buy it directly. I mean, we do sell wine direct to consumer, so, um, we, and that is the best way to sort of guarantee getting what you want and knowing that it's coming straight from our cellar.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Beth Novak
And therefore, it's in the best condition or ideally. Um, but obviously if you have a good relationship with a, you know, a strong relationship with a retailer that you, that you value, buy, buy from them. But it's, it's pretty minimally, you know, you might find it, but it's, it's going to come in and sort of go out quickly because there's not a lot of wine. So these aren't, nobody's getting large allocations.
Lindy Novak
Or you can go to our website, which is spottswoode.com. You can call us-
Doug Shafer
Spottswoode.com. Phone number in the book, on the website?
Lindy Novak
Phone number, should, would you like us to give you the phone number on air?
Doug Shafer
You know something?
Beth Novak
You just said the book, but there-
Doug Shafer
I said the book, the telephone book. (Laughter) Someone dropped one on my driveway.
Beth Novak
Right and you just recycled because you don't need it and and what are you doing? A phone book?
Doug Shafer
I was like, no, I went out just like I went out to get the paper and there was another thing, there was a telephone book and I was like, "Oh my."
Beth Novak
Oh my.
Lindy Novak
I still, I still see those in a cupboard just because-
Doug Shafer
I was like, "Oh my." I-
Beth Novak
Yeah. Do you ever reference it? I just, I think it's - stop doing it, I put it right in the recycler.
Lindy Novak
I can't bear to put it immediately in the recycler. I put in a cupboard pretending I'm going to look at it sometimes and then don't.
Doug Shafer
(Laughter) I think you do it the next time a new one comes in.
Lindy Novak
Yeah. Exactly. Exactly.
Doug Shafer
All right. Fair enough. Well, all right, you two. Thanks for coming. It was great.
Beth Novak
Thanks for having us.
Lindy Novak
Thank you very much, that was fun.
Beth Novak
Appreciate it very much, it's been fun.
Doug Shafer
Right.
Lindy Novak
And you were right it wasn't too nerve wracking.
Doug Shafer
I told you.
Lindy Novak
Okay. Thanks.
Doug Shafer
Piece of cake.






